Re:Why pessimism on Social Security could come back to bite ...
by howard941 on Thursday May 23, 2019 @02:23PM
(#19994430)
Another way to get $2T is to just spend it and not be overly concerned with debt.
Re:Why pessimism on Social Security could come back to bite ...
by tptacek on Thursday May 23, 2019 @08:52PM
(#19997493)
Can we put aside the financing part of this and just address how crazy this suggestion is just as a matter of common sense? Our country pays significantly more than its peers do on health care. The crisis in health care isn't that it's not universally free, but that it costs too damn much. The "just put $2T on the debit card" answer to that problem says, ok, fuck it, the systems that are overcharging us for care, leave them alone, give them their money, and let's figure this out later. But that money is going somewhere. Of all the places the federal government can route a dollar, how does it make sense to send it to companies that are, deliberately or unintentionally (through inefficiency), overcharging us? How is that not just abject surrender?
Re:Why pessimism on Social Security could come back to bite ...
by rayiner on Thursday May 23, 2019 @02:50PM
(#19994681)
I think we can sustain some deficit spending. But $2 trillion annually would triple the deficit.
Re:Why pessimism on Social Security could come back to bite ...
by AlexTWithBeard on Thursday May 23, 2019 @02:34PM
(#19994529)
Works like a charm until the money has to be repaid.
Re:Why pessimism on Social Security could come back to bite ...
by howard941 on Thursday May 23, 2019 @05:06PM
(#19995954)
Does the charm last when it's never repaid? See for ex https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/02/why-the...
Contra: Before the dot com crash and 9/11 some non-lunatics were worrying that Treasuries would go away and there'd be no safe place to store money because all the debt looked like it was going to be paid off before too long.
Re:Why pessimism on Social Security could come back to bite ...
by AlexTWithBeard on Thursday May 23, 2019 @06:09PM
(#19996526)
Saying that the countries do not die, as the referenced article suggests is not right: states do disappear every once in a while. Yes, their lifespan is usually longer than for humans a but it's not infinite.
But even looking at mortal humans: in 2008 many of them have realized that no, it's not possible to keep borrowing indefinitely. Some day the creditors may ask for their money back.
Some people suggest we'll just print the money we need. The problem is that now I can take this money and buy half of your country before you realize what's going on.
You can’t raise an additional $2 trillion a year with a 70% tax rate on millionaires or eliminating the inheritance tax or treating capital gains like income or cutting the military budget. None of that even gets you close. $2 trillion is the entire income of the top 1%, or all the profits earned by US corporations. (Because of dividends and whatnot, a lot of corporate profits are income to the top 1% so there is a huge overlap between those. And you’re already taxing those two groups almost $800 billion a year. You’d have to raise it to $2.8 trillion a year.) The total income of people making above $1 million (much less the $10 million mark AOC has cited) is $700 billion.
You couldn't even raise that money with an "all of the above" approach. Say you doubled the income tax on the top 1% (+500 billion), eliminated the preferential tax treatment for capital gains (+$130 billion), doubled corporate taxes (+$200 billion), and slashed the defense budget to the NATO target of 2% of GDP (+200 billion). You're still only at $1 trillion (barely enough to close the deficit). You've also pushed the U.S. income and corporate tax burden far above the level in our competitor countries like the U.K., Germany, France, Italy, and Spain: https://data.oecd.org/tax/tax-on-personal-income.htm#indicat... https://data.oecd.org/tax/tax-on-corporate-profits.htm#indic....
There are a few ways to get $2 trillion. You could raise income taxes from 10% of GDP, about the OECD average, to 20% of GDP. That would blow past Sweden levels of income taxes (13% of GDP) into Denmark territory. Like Denmark, you’d have to make the income tax extremely broad based. The top tax rate of 56% (combined municipal, national, and labor contribution) kicks in at under $80,000. The tax rate below that is essentially flat, at 40%, with some deductions. (Fun fact: Denmark’s corporate tax rate is just 25%, lower than the US average after accounting for state corporate taxes.)
Or, you could create a 20% VAT to get our consumption taxes up from 4.3% to the OECD average of about 10%: https://data.oecd.org/tax/tax-on-goods-and-services.htm#indi.... And you could increase FICA taxes to 25% or so (from 15%) to get our 6.3% social insurance tax rate up to the OECD average of 9%. That, plus a millionaire's tax, if you're so inclined, will get you to $2 trillion.
All of these would impose a large tax increase in the middle class. That’s politically untenable even for Democrats. That’s why you see things like the Sanders health plan, that has like a half-page bullet point list of possible revenue sources (none of which comes close to raising 10% of GDP in tax revenue). There is only a single way to increase U.S. taxes to European levels without rendering ourselves economically noncompetitive by taxing high earners and corporations more than Europe. And that is massive tax increases on the middle class. Democrats are willfully blind to that reality.