News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon shareholders reject facial recognition ban by mc32 on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @07:09PM (#19986601)
Public corporations, private corporations, state-owned, party-controlled corporations. It doesn’t matter. At least public corporations are known to bow to pressure.

I think ownership is irrelevant. What matters is lawfulness and what remains lawful after pressure or indifference from the constituencies.

Hand in hand with this is the rule of law. Some countries on paper have great liberties and rights for their people, but in practice it’s up to the party to interpret and enforce (as in the great purges, etc,)

Re:Amazon shareholders reject facial recognition ban by roenxi on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @08:05PM (#19986981)
> What matters is lawfulness and what remains lawful

To expand on that idea - if something is both lawful and profitable, you have to have an almost absolute consensus amongst the people capable of doing it that it should not be done. Otherwise, potentially even if 1 person thinks it is fine, then they will be the one to do it.

Typically this is the main strength of the economic system - jobs that people don't want to do get allocated to the person who has the least problem with doing it.

The threat here was never the development of the technology - it is obvious that it is coming - the issue here is government demand. A corporation can only do so much with my face that annoys me - the government on the other hand can make life really miserable.

Re:Amazon shareholders reject facial recognition ban by solveit on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @08:55PM (#19987275)
> if something is both lawful and profitable, you have to have an almost absolute consensus amongst the people capable of doing it that it should not be done.

Sure, but you just need a weak consensus amongst everyone that it should not be done to make it unlawful.

Re:Amazon shareholders reject facial recognition ban by itslennysfault on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @08:12PM (#19987026)
There are B-Corps (benefit corp) in many states that have charters that include bylaws that are as important or at least equally as important as profitability. IMO all health providers should have to be B-Corps that have patient health as their #1 above profit.
Re:Amazon shareholders reject facial recognition ban by vonmoltke on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @09:04PM (#19987322)
"B-Corp" is a certification[1]. It has no force of law anywhere. It has nothing to do with a benefit corporation[2], which does.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/B_Corporation_(certification...

[2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benefit_corporation

Re:Amazon shareholders reject facial recognition ban by llamataboot on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @07:34PM (#19986751)
I would agree with you entirely and I think that the history of both capitalism and communism have demonstrated that we are not at a level yet where we can design a socio-economic system to make it not matter whether we are good to each other and in fact, they are both likely, in different ways, to sometimes distort and amplify some of the worst parts of our animal natures.

I have found it a certainty on HN that at some point, in any discussion of these things, that someone will step in and say "but this is legal, and the corporation must maximize its profits for the shareholders, so if you really want a change, change the laws, the company itself is utterly amoral and working as designed"

Re:Amazon shareholders reject facial recognition ban by andrepd on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @08:25PM (#19987109)
It's always good to remind: lawful != moral/ethical. Sometimes the law is twisted and wrong, and it needs to change.
Re:Amazon shareholders reject facial recognition ban by mc32 on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @08:30PM (#19987133)
Very true. And ethics change over time. Laws change over time. But people want immediate reconciliation with their beliefs —which can be at odds with that of others. So we have to rely on the law.

Prohibition is a great example of what laws can do, good and bad. After lots of bloodletting we realized it wasn’t good and we were not benefitting from it so it was reversed.

[dead]
Re:Amazon shareholders reject facial recognition ban by tomhoward on Thursday May 23, 2019 @01:41AM (#19988822)
> Yeah but everyone on this site will tell you that laws and regulations are horrid evil things

Haven't you seen any of the discussions on this site about topics like Facebook, Google, Uber, GDPR, climate change, and how much support there is for government intervention?

Being a large global community that attracts people of a broad range of backgrounds and worldviews, sentiment is anything but uniform on topics like these.

If that weren't the case, nobody would bother coming here as there'd be nothing to discuss :)

Re:Amazon shareholders reject facial recognition ban by JohnFen on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @07:31PM (#19986737)
Not everyone. I happen to think that laws and regulations can be wonderful things.
Re:Amazon shareholders reject facial recognition ban by ljm on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @07:45PM (#19986826)
It strikes me as odd that we accept and even celebrate law and order for the individual person, but many people balk as soon as the same standard is applied to an organisation.

The war on drugs and mass incarceration of weed smokers is fine. Regulating a woman's body by banning abortion is fine. Regulating against a woman to protect the rights of a rapist is fine. Regulating sexuality is fine.

But regulate ISPs, or Hollywood, or financial institutions, or Walmart or Amazon, or whatever other corporation? Oh hell no, that's a cardinal sin. You can't get in the way of money.

I think that running a business should be a privilege, one that can be properly revoked when the business fails to serve the society it depends on.

Re:Amazon shareholders reject facial recognition ban by mlazos on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @08:05PM (#19986978)
I honestly don’t think any of the social issues you mention are accepted wholeheartedly by society. And I also don’t think the regulations you talk about are generally rejected by society. Just here on HN you can see how heated the discussion gets about regulating amazon. I’m pretty sure the government already has the power to fine or breakup businesses that brazenly break the law, but the system isn’t efficient because businesses can argue their case in court. I think my point is these problems aren’t trivial and your solution is right at a high level, but actually implementing it in a way that is fair is really difficult.
Re:Amazon shareholders reject facial recognition ban by Causality1 on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @08:16PM (#19987041)
"I'll believe corporations are people when Texas executes one."
Re:Amazon shareholders reject facial recognition ban by munk-a on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @07:25PM (#19986703)
I mean, not everyone... in fact I've always sort of assumed that those that push hard against regulations are the silicon valley crowd of folks - and you folks are fine folks, but that part of the world is just weird.