One reason—not one I necessarily endorse, but a possibility—might be a conviction that people really aren't very good, deep down. Perhaps its cousin conviction that I'm not really all that good deep down.
Put another way, it may be rooted not in a protective mechanism about disappointment as much as a persuasion about human nature.
Without deathism, race could go extinct during famine. Opposite, during nice times, longer life has evolutionary benefit via mentoring, safety etc.
On a slightly unrelated note: making a blanket list of arguments you disagree with and then dismissing them all rarely leads (in my opinion) to a productive discussion.
Appeal to authority at best. Rather than "I said so", you're pulling a "he said so" - not much better.
But i think The biggest benefit would be the ability for a society to pursue long term projects because you will actually see the benefits even if it takes a 100 years.
> Curing aging isn't immortality. You die at 600 on average by accident.
So the problem is reduced to having a good body shield and few extra planets.
More people make more progress faster. Aren’t you glad your parents didn't decide the world would be prettier or work better without you in it? If great minds like Einstein, Bell, Tesla, Da Vinci etc., were still alive and productive today, the world would be a better place. You're literally asking for others to die out of your fear. The burden should be higher. Have courage. If living longer comes with too many disadvantages, we'll know 100 years from now and decide then.
Man up, save your family, save yourself.
P.S. Curing aging isn't immortality. You die at 600 on average by accident, and if the parade of imaginary horrible things comes true, even earlier.