News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by tptacek on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:31PM (#19966325)
So, the worst impulses of both extremes? Where do I sign?

It's not even clear what this modest proposal has to do with the article, which is written from the premise that the whole enterprise of college-oriented secondary schooling is misguided, that no matter how well-taught the subjects, secondary school educational objectives are about signaling --- to colleges --- and not human capital, and that there's even more broad acceptance of the notion that college is itself about signaling to the labor market.

How would privatizing schools address this person's concerns?

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by AnimalMuppet on Monday May 20, 2019 @07:48PM (#19966424)
You would get charter schools that emphasized signalling. You might get some that emphasized human capital. That would leave parents able to choose - if they actually perceived what was going on.

As it is, though, if I want actual human capital in my child's education, it's either private school or homeschooling. To the degree (if any) that private schools emphasize human capital over signalling, I'm not sure that privatizing schools plus vouchers would make them change to emphasizing signalling. So I don't think the situation would become worse, and it might become better.

Re:Letter from an “Anti-School Teacher” by JamesBarney on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @01:44AM (#19967817)
The biggest problem with education is that who the kid is(smart, hard working, resilient) has 20x the impact of his education. So it's much easier to select 5% better students than it is to teach them 100% better. And if teams of phd researchers are arguing over whether colleges in general are signalling versus human capital, how are some random parents going to be to solve the much harder problem of if a single school's results are due to signalling or human capital with less time, training, and information?