This sort of stuff is exactly why the separate kitchen doesn't work at our house. The kids want to be where they can see us, and, with the way our kitchen is set up, there's no way for them to do that without being underfoot. At the same time, we want to be able to keep at least a vague eye on them, and that's not not really possible if they're in a completely separate room.
Versus, when I was little, our house had a kitchen that was separated from the living room by a counter. Which things much easier: We could hang out in sight of Mom, Mom could keep an eyey on us, and we weren't creating a safety hazard (or hassle) just so long as we stayed on one side of the counter.
It's also a total PITA at dinner parties. These aren't the old days, where it was OK for one person (always the same person) to stay isolated in the kitchen for half the evening, and it was understood that it's a private space where guests aren't allowed. Instead we end up with more and more people congregating in the kitchen, socializing with the cook and then with each other, until eventually literally every guest is there, getting in the way of the cooking, and they all have to get kicked out so that we can open the oven safely. Then you're isolated for a little bit, until someone needs to get another beer from the fridge, and ends up staying in the kitchen to chat, and then another, and it slowly ramps up until a mildly dangerous cacophany again. Rinse and repeat until dinner is served.
Unless something absolutely amazing is happening in the living room, the smokers will be out back, a pair of introverts will be in the hallway, and everyone else will slowly gravitate towards the kitchen until everyone is in the way.
When the available seating is exhausted in the living room, it feels a bit strange to remain standing if everyone else is sitting, so you excuse yourself to the kitchen for another drink, where you find a number of other people standing and conversing. This feels less strange, so you don't see much point in going back to the living room.
Once everyone has made the inevitable trip to the kitchen to freshen up their beverage, and gets caught up in a conversation in the kitchen, the living room gradually becomes empty, and at that point, nobody wants to go sit alone in the living room and miss all the action happening in the kitchen.
It smells amazing too being near the action. Sight + smell getting stimulated all at once.
[0] https://www.ana-white.com/woodworking-projects/little-helper...
Though, some kids are easier than others to redirect.
Oh, that feeling of taking a drink of something opaque, and feeling unexpected solid items in your mouth...
As are parents. Some of this might be introversion versus extraversion.
IMHO having a cavalier attitude because nothing bad happened to you is not productive.
This happened to a friend's kid. He pulled down a pot of spaghetti, severely burning his penis. While the family is struggling to deal with the medical issue, Massachusetts starts an intrusive and accusatory investigation. Because of the location of the injury, the state made the assumption that there was sexual abuse.
For all the reasons you listed I want it open so I can keep an eye on the kids.
When you have small kids:
- You want them away from boiling water, dropped knives, and dangerously hot ovens.
- You want them to keep sleeping even though you're vacuuming
- You might want to let them watch Baby Shark for the 1000th blasted time while leaving you out of it
- You might want to read a novel while they hold miniature My Little Pony melodramas
- You might want to start a project on a table, leave it alone for an hour (behind closed doors), then come back to it where you left it
- You might want to have adult conversations about adult subjects (death, money, parenting) without unprepared ears listening in
You probably do want to incorporate them into dining, family choices, and cooking, but only in controlled ways.