News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by alanh on Saturday December 11, 2010 @11:34PM (#1996442)
Remember how everyone likes to note that Apple is never afraid to obsolete itself? Killing OS 9 to start completely new in OS X… Aggressively and constantly re-imagining the iPod… Replacing the iPod (effectively) with a completely new touch-based system (iOS)… beginning the revolution from PCs to iPad-style devices (they are selling as many iPads as they are computers, now).

When has Blackberry ever really dared to cannibalize itself?

Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by wallflower on Sunday December 12, 2010 @01:12AM (#1996614)
> Killing OS 9 to start completely new in OS X

WWDC 2002: Steve Jobs presides over the funeral for 'The Death of Mac OS 9'

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cl7xQ8i3fc0

Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by deepu_256 on Sunday December 12, 2010 @01:23AM (#1996631)
Cannibalization is not the norm. There are many successful platforms which didn't go the route of cannibalization. Ex - windows.

The OS 9 - OS 10 example is more of an exception than the norm. In the case of OS 9 everyone(even Apple people) knew it sucked big time. They tried hard for several years to fix it's problems or try to develop a new one. There was no way for them to continue with OS 9.

RIM isn't exactly is in such a bad situation. Agreed that they need to woo developers much much more to their platform but that doesn't warrant cannibalization. They should continue innovating but should be more evolutionary.

The bad thing is that for a long time RIM sat on it's laurels without much innovation. Good thing is that they still haven't lost the market share. They already moved from their strong place of qwerty keyboards to touch screens. Much more innovation is needed. Not just copying others but having a vision of the future and then aggressively executing on that vision. They did it once before which made Blackberry such a cracking brand. Now they should do it again.

Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by alanh on Sunday December 12, 2010 @01:33AM (#1996637)
Eh, even Windows could be argued to have followed this pattern, with Windows NT. Different foundation. They did end up supporting the 9.x APIs on the NT platform, to create Windows XP, but the fact is they still released a “competing” version of Windows first.
Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by martythemaniak on Sunday December 12, 2010 @11:09PM (#1999277)
For some reason RIM gets little but hate around this place (maybe because it doesn't make products for hackers and it competes with Apple), but I think their story is actually quite inspiring.

Mike Lizaridis quit engineering school a early to found RIM in 1984 in a tech backwater. He struggled for a decade, but slowly built up the company over a decade to around 100 people. They then hit a rough patch and had a tough round of layoffs, but survived. 15 years after they were founded, they hit upon both a brilliant idea and execution. When the BlackBerry was released in 1999, RIM had around 120 people and sold 25000 of the units. Over the last decade, they have managed to fend off all big tech companies while growing into a global brand a major tech company. Meanwhile, Mike L has funded one of the coolest charities around (Perimeter Institute) and RIM has turned Waterloo into a major tech center.

So, to answer your glib question: many times between 84 and 99, once around 2003 (replacing an old OS) and right now (with the move to QNX and webos-like SDK).

Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by pwpwp on Sunday December 12, 2010 @01:51AM (#1996658)
Why do you glorify doing something new and stupid, when doing good things well is what people really should be admiring. — Linus Torvalds
Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by Andys on Sunday December 12, 2010 @02:37AM (#1996714)
Ironic, given my perception of Linux as doing good things in a mediocre way...
Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by Stormbringer on Sunday December 12, 2010 @07:35AM (#1996971)
Apologises for 'wall of text'(tm) (patent pending) TLDR: move along, nothing to see here

If you're one of the people who likes fiddling around with your computer, and having very fine grained control over the OS, then Linux is pretty near perfect.

If you just want to use your computer to do work, if you want an integrated and unified user experience* that makes it easy to move from one app to another, if you are... dare I say it, a consumer, then Linux may be less than optimal.

However, remember that even Mac OS X is built on BSD. Now, my impression of the Linux vs BSD spectrum is that BSD used to have a small advantage, but Linuxes large dev base has more than caught up to BSD and continues to pull ahead of it at a steady (if not spectacular) rate. It is not difficult to imagine that in 5-10 years time Linux will be 2-5 times 'better' than BSD. If, at that time, someone with good taste and a decent usability team went and did to Linux what OS X did to BSD, then they could bury the Mac.

This is my definition of a power user -> someone who _uses_ the computer to do _powerful_ things. And I have no snobbery here, I consider programming to be (typically) a 'shallow' use of the computer, and I don't make distinctions between someone who does amazing things in Excel, and someone who does amazing things with home movie or music composition software.

*You might imagine this is a not so thinly veiled reference to Apple users ... however I don't consider Apple to be 'perfect' in this regard. In fact, it feels like most of the time their usability/product design is mediocre at best, sometimes even bad or downright awful ... the problem is that no one else is even _trying_.

Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by Andys on Sunday December 12, 2010 @08:45PM (#1998864)
Actually I was only really talking about the Linux kernel itself (which is what Linus has dominion over). For just one example, look at the multi-threaded performance of the scheduler versus other kernels.
Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by macrael on Sunday December 12, 2010 @01:20PM (#1997528)
Just my own ignorance here, but I'd love to hear what you like better about linux than BSD. I don't know a lot about the advantages of linux.
Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by Stormbringer on Sunday December 12, 2010 @02:21PM (#1997720)
I'm making the argument that Linux (with a larger developer base) is capable of matching any feature in BSD, while still having cycles to spare for improving its own base in terms of speed, reliability, web pages served etc.

I didn't realise this was still controversial, my impression was that benchmarks had shown back in 2006 (or earlier) that Linux had caught up to BSD, and since at that time it had a faster rate of change, I assumed that would continue, and extrapolated the trend.

It has been so long since I saw a serious discussion about whether Linux or BSD was better that I assumed it was a moot point by now. If that is _not_ actually the case, then mad props to the BSD devs for doing more with less. I don't follow Linux development trends, if the number of kernel developers has fallen off in the last couple of years that would be a shame, but perhaps not surprising, as a lot of dev work gets moved behind closed doors (cough Google and other 'cloud' companies uncough) or you might argue that once Linux gets to a certain percentage of 'perfection' that there are fewer and fewer 'itches to scratch', and less urgency to scratch them (as a kludgy workaround may present itself)

Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by bmelton on Sunday December 12, 2010 @09:13AM (#1997098)
The thing you mention though hasn't happened -- nobody's taken Linux to anywhere near the level of polish found in OS X.

I think Canonical is the obvious front-runner in that regard, and while they're making leaps and bounds, I've found nothing in Ubuntu that comes anywhere near the level of fit and finish available in almost every single OS X application.

Functionally, the Ubuntu equivalents are close, but from a usability perspective, they're a very long way away.

Perhaps dropping Xorg is the push that things need to make this happen? I honestly don't know, but while OS X is iterating even more towards perfection, simply moving the control icons to the other side of the title bar in Ubuntu caused an uproar. I think the community at large is too big and stubborn to allow a complete makeover similar to the OS9 OS X transition.

Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by Stormbringer on Sunday December 12, 2010 @02:11PM (#1997695)
From my experience, I've found a good Linux setup to be about as good as Windows. It doesn't have to be Ubuntu of course, just that (probably) Ubuntu is less work to put into that state.

But my needs are modest, email, web browser, text editor and a compiler. I'm much more interested in the _stability_ of an OS install than tinkering with its innards. I don't want it doing strange stuff to itself when I'm not looking.

None of the big three OSes is perfect, all are improving. Typically in different ways, depending on the core values of their developers and user base.

Canonical _cannot_ beat OS X at what OS X is good at (integration), without ditching its Linux values (freedom for the developer to do whatever he wants). Because that kind of deep integration requires one person (or a group that all thinks the same way) to stand up and say "this is how it is going to be". On Linux, even _Linus_ cannot do that.

On the other hand, you can do what OS X did with BSD - put lipstick on the pig. They build on a foundation of open source tools, but then they commit to providing a slew of (moderately consistent) GUIs for those tools. Note: the command line didn't go away in OS X, but infrequent tasks are much easier with a consistent GUI than if you have to read 20+ pages of man in order to figure out the correct invocations... in that regard, for the 'non-fiddlers' like me OS X is the best of both worlds.

Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by anonymous246 on Sunday December 12, 2010 @02:50PM (#1997818)
"email, web browser, text editor and a compiler" and Ubuntu manages to screw up even this. I somehow find that Ubuntu seems to have less vertical space on the same laptop than Windows. Too many window bars etc. The consolas programmer-friendly font renders better under Windows (maybe patent problems), so my preferred way to work "on Linux" is to ssh using a full-screen putty to a tmux session running on Linux.

It almost seems like all the elves left the world of Unix in the early 80s, and nothing imagined after the 80s is actually of any use (X11 onwards).

And I take it you don't own a smartphone and hence are uninterested in viewing/organizing photos and videos (forget editing videos!). Ubuntu's tools have always been pathetic.

The ease of use of iPhoto and iMovie is ASTOUNDING. And from the "tinkering" point of view, apparently Apple provides scriptable APIs for almost all of iPhoto's functionality; and in the worst case you can just 'cd' into the iPhoto database (all photos in a single giant file!) with command line tools (like 'find', 'cp' etc) and DIY.

Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by quadhome on Sunday December 12, 2010 @09:10AM (#1997095)
In 2-5 years, will the "Mac" product be relevant?
Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by revorad on Sunday December 12, 2010 @09:57AM (#1997163)
Because doing something new and stupid often leads to great things?
Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by dshanley on Sunday December 12, 2010 @02:40AM (#1996718)
They haven't, but they are currently in the process of trying to reinvent their OS - with QNX. Except, they are launching this OS, but leaving all their Java devs behind. The OS launches on the Playbook with only C++ and Flash support if you can believe it. I don't expect them to have significant market share in two years from now.
Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by gnufreex on Sunday December 12, 2010 @02:22AM (#1996701)
About Apple killing classic MacOS, it was really kill or be killed. They did it years too late, IMHO.
Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by philwelch on Sunday December 12, 2010 @11:59AM (#1997334)
Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by isani on Monday December 13, 2010 @06:49AM (#2000136)
You could add Newton OS to that list. It was an attempt to do what iOS achieved: a move out of the Mac into mobile devices. Apple initially planned to implement a large number of mobile form factors based on Newton.
Re:What's really wrong with BlackBerry by gnufreex on Wednesday December 15, 2010 @12:52AM (#2007209)
They also fumbled with MkLinux and BeOS, IIRC.