News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by colordrops on Monday May 20, 2019 @03:22PM (#19964026)
Chernobyl only took out 10,000 square miles because they got lucky. If they didn't drain water tanks it could have exploded making a huge portion of the continent uninhabitable.

Also, using 17,500 square miles doesn't equal damage. The land could be reclaimed in negligible time by removing the panels, unlike nuclear contamination.

Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by DuskStar on Monday May 20, 2019 @03:38PM (#19964228)
> Chernobyl only took out 10,000 square miles because they got lucky.

The Chernobyl exclusion zone is a tenth of that - 1,000 square miles. 10,000 square miles is the total from one accident per decade and an average exclusion zone duration of 100 years.

> If they didn't drain water tanks it could have exploded making a huge portion of the continent uninhabitable.

It would have made a large part of the continent have higher radiation doses, but even with linear-no-threshold I don't think that France/UK/Spain/Italy would have been uninhabitable. Or even close to that. And the point was, even with the most incompetent leadership we've seen at a nuclear power plant, that didn't happen.

> Also, using 17,500 square miles doesn't equal damage. The land could be reclaimed in negligible time by removing the panels, unlike nuclear contamination.

Well, sure - you can take the solar panels and move them somewhere else if you want. But if you're using solar for power, you can't really get rid of them - just move them around.

Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by gjm11 on Monday May 20, 2019 @03:34PM (#19964175)
> it could have exploded making a huge portion of the continent uninhabitable

Some details and references for this would be nice. I find it hard to believe, though of course sometimes things I find hard to believe turn out to be true :-).

Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by DuskStar on Monday May 20, 2019 @03:47PM (#19964331)
The area under the reactor core was filled with water, and if the corium (molten core material) had contacted that water it would have caused a steam explosion and launched additional material outside of the reactor building.

There's an interesting StackOverflow post relating to this here: [0] That just deals with the size of the steam explosion though, not the potential effects. (And for reference, I've seen the largest explosion that did occur listed as ~10T equivalent)

0: https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/480113/how-large...

Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by gjm11 on Monday May 20, 2019 @08:10PM (#19966555)
The thing I'm skeptical about is the claim that this would have rendered a large part of the continent uninhabitable. The Stack Exchange discussion is interesting but (as you say) doesn't really bear on that.
Re:U.S. put nuclear waste under a dome on a Pacific island. ... by DuskStar on Monday May 20, 2019 @08:43PM (#19966696)
Yeah - worst case was 20x more radioactive material (well, I suppose no-seriously-wtf case would be 80x, but that requires the other three active reactors to have gone up as well) since at least 5% of the reactor core was released.