News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Depression-Gene Studies Were Built on Shaky Foundations by unityByFreedom on Monday May 20, 2019 @09:12AM (#19959956)
> We're discussing his criticism of how a ton of "real psychiatrists" got some major things wrong

No, you replied to me. My comment was it is strange that this Atlantic article cites him as "the psychiatrist Scott Alexander" because that is a pen name, and it isn't verifiable that he is a psychiatrist due to his anonymity.

Your refutation of my point is "it doesn't matter that it isn't verifiable", but that was part of my point. You can't just toss it out, that's being intellectually dishonest.

Any piece of journalism that cites a person should do so only if they can verify the source. Journalists who skip this step means at least a portion of their article is fake news.

> You shouldn't blindly trust a blog post about this topic just because the author is verifiably a psychiatrist, but you shouldn't blindly distrust one just because they are not

This has nothing to do with my point, which is all about how The Atlantic journalist cites him, and has little to do with whatever his blog says.

Re:Depression-Gene Studies Were Built on Shaky Foundations by skybrian on Monday May 20, 2019 @11:46AM (#19961596)
You're assuming without evidence that Ed Yong didn't verify his credentials. How do you know? Maybe ask?
Re:Depression-Gene Studies Were Built on Shaky Foundations by unityByFreedom on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @03:42AM (#19968265)
Again, the author cited him as "the psychiatrist Scott Alexander".

If he did verify credentials, he ought to have mentioned the name is an alias.

Re:Depression-Gene Studies Were Built on Shaky Foundations by skybrian on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @08:36PM (#19976615)
He could have mentioned it, but I don't understand why you think it's important?

The authors of the actual scientific study are Richard Border and his co-authors. Scott Alexander is just a well-known blogger who gets credit for writing about it in a vivid way that got people's attention. He's not a primary source, so for the purposes of this article, it doesn't really matter whether he's using an alias or even whether he's a psychiatrist. (It's not a credential in the relevant field anyway.) You can verify the quotes by following the link.

Calling up other scientists in the field and asking questions about a scientific paper is how science writers verify a science article, and Ed Yong did that.

Re:Depression-Gene Studies Were Built on Shaky Foundations by unityByFreedom on Wednesday May 22, 2019 @12:30AM (#19977771)
> I don't understand why you think it's important?

Scott Alexander is a pseudoynm. Journalists referencing that name should note this, along with the fact that his credentials as a psychiatrist are not publicly verifiable.

Re:Depression-Gene Studies Were Built on Shaky Foundations by DataWorker on Monday May 20, 2019 @09:58AM (#19960354)
Perhaps publish or parish applies to journalism as well. Factchecking costs money and not everyone has ssc’s budget.
Re:Depression-Gene Studies Were Built on Shaky Foundations by unityByFreedom on Tuesday May 21, 2019 @03:50AM (#19968291)
> Factchecking costs money

Authors who do not fact-check are writing fiction. That is not journalism.

> not everyone has ssc’s budget

What budget? It's one or a handful of people writing a blog. I'm sure the budget of The Atlantic, founded in the 1800s, dwarfs that of SSC.