Re:Depression-Gene Studies Were Built on Shaky Foundations
by thanatropism on Monday May 20, 2019 @09:20AM
(#19960023)
Yes, but Huntington's is an explicit cluster of symptoms at diagnosis + a specific prognosis. Uppercase D "Depression" is a diagnosis built around a single symptom, lowercase d "depression". But many people experience depression, both in "core mental illnesses" like bipolar and outside. (Note how bipolar is much better constructed -- indeed the method of differential diagnosis was invented by Kraepelin to differentiate bipolar from schizophrenia)
If it was up to me, big D Depression would be redefined as "responds to Prozac" or something.
Why? There are other complex diseases with purely genetic causes, e.g. Huntington's Disease; depression isn't necessarily different. Hindsight is 20/20.