As to why this is the case, I think maybe this is enabled by Go's backward's compatibility focus and encouragement to upgrade early and often, and the community's focus to utilize small interfaces sometimes from the stdlib itself, like io.Reader and io.Writer, or http.Handler. Added to that w.r.t. using the latest and greatest, most Go users frequently are using the latest version of Go even in production (per the go experience surveys).
I am sure it also helps that Google pays people to develop, maintain, and improve the stdlib.
CompressedSize uint32 // Deprecated: Use CompressedSize64 instead.
CompressedSize64 uint64 // Go 1.1
// Deprecated: HeaderMap exists for historical compatibility
// and should not be used.
Requirements may change over time, so even getting something perfect now is not a guarantee it will last (e.g. pre-UTF-8 languages froze byte-oriented or UCS-2 strings, even though these were good decisions at the time).Sometimes improvements are not worth the cost of deprecation and replacement, so things are just left as they are. For example, an HTTP interface designed for request-response HTTP/1 works for stream-oriented HTTP/2, but support for push, prioritization and custom frames is bolted on. Packet-oriented HTTP/3 will add even more stuff that will have to be retrofitted somehow to the old model. Libraries can come and go, but std can't just throw away an old interface and start over.
- What would you define as a while? I think Go has done well with it, given that it is almost 10 years old now at this point, and in reality, was in development internally at Google years before that.
- Do you feel like an interface being frozen forever is particularly a bad thing in of itself? What if the interface does a really good job describing the thing, whatever it may be? For example, Go's io.Reader/io.Writer interfaces.
I agree sometimes an interface being frozen is bad, but for example when Go standardized the context package, it simply added "Context" to the existing functions that now take a context (e.g. in the database/sql package, you have the old, Exec, Query, QueryRow functions, and after 1.8 you have ExecContext, QueryContext, QueryRowContext, which some people may view as a reason to have method overloading, but I view as adding better clarity.
Rust libraries should be expected to take a few tries to get right, especially earlier in its lifecycle. There's more possibilities and less experience in the language.
You can see a similar effect in Haskell, which has iterated many basic bits of functionality many times over.
I read some discussion the other day about some ways in which the Any type in Rust isn’t as flexible as it could be, since it is frozen the only way to improve it would be to introduce a new name, such as Unknown. Similarly in C# along with adding async support, the standard library added async versions of many methods, eg Read now also has a ReadAsync partner.
It does seem that having multiple names for basically the same thing adds a small but tolerable level of overhead to a language. At least if as much as possible is moved out, then projects can choose to only use the latest versions, and live in a world as if past versions never existed.
The example of random number generators is a good one, too. There are a lot of applications that require (reproducable!) PRNG sequences and sometimes you have to share PRNGs between modules. Now, looking at the rand crate, I see that the prng part of it was recently mucked around with. If I have two 3rd party modules that I require to share a PRNG that I control (say, noise generators for procedural textures), I cannot compose them if one of them uses the old and one of them uses the new version of the library.
• crates that expect to be used for interoperability are often split into smaller crates (like API and back-end, or low-level API and high-level API), so that they can evolve some parts without breaking others.
• sometimes breaking changes are technically breaking, but easy to upgrade (e.g. methods renamed, args reordered). In that case most users catch up quickly.
• in desperate cases, a new version can import its own old version and re-export old structs and interfaces that haven't changed, so they're compatible across major versions.
• proper sharing and composition should be done via traits, so that you can implement a trait for any number generator, not just one version of one implementation.
Maybe in the future we'll see more hacking of libraries (people managing to deliberately sneak exploits in) and in response stronger lockdowns on important library code.
In Rust, libstd is mainly for interfacing with the compiler and providing interoperability between packages (crates). The wider crate ecosystem is the real standard library, since external crates are as easy to use as the standard library.
For example, the libstd doesn't even have support for random number generation. There's a rand crate, which is now on 6th major breaking version. That's perfectly fine, because multiple versions can coexist in one program, and every user can upgrade (or not) at their own pace. And the crate was able to refine its interface six times, instead of being stuck with the first try forever.