It was only the market on a single exchange, Bitstamp, which is extremelly illiquid compared to the largest exchanges. The problem was that Bitmex, a much more liquid exchange, bases the settlement price of its popular perpetual Bitcoin swap on an index of just two exchanges, Bitstamp and one other, so manipulating the price on illiquid Bitstamp also screws with the price on liquid Bitmex.
However, if the issue was only a thin market on Bitstamp, the price fluctuations would have remained localized to Bitstamp and the futures market on Bitmex. But instead the price for bitcoin dropped by about $1k across the board, which to me signals thin markets everywhere.
The real problem is that the exchanges all have separate order books, and it's hard to arbitrage between them.
This is a recipe for volatility.
Also, I wasn't saying anything about slow speeds. I was saying that the ability of the market, on a single smaller exchange, to absorb a $40 million trade in 20 minutes is not traditionally what you'd call a thin market.
To the point that, hmm, you could just trade with yourself to pump or dump the price.
A market composed of yourself and yourself is, by any measure, pretty thin.
https://medium.com/@bitfinexed/wash-trading-bitcoin-how-bitf...
Also, the slow speed of price propagation isn’t a sign that the market is thick, it’s a sign that the market is inefficient.