Do you have a specific technical criticism of the secure aggregation protocol? That’s what’s supposed to make it impossible to deduce the data from model updates. Or is your concern something else?
I hadn't really read it at that point. It more seemed like a too big achievement for me to believe that anyone could solve.
One issue with their approach I found while causally browsing is
"for the proof against active adversaries, we assume that there exists a public-key infras-tructure (PKI), which guarantees to users that messages they receive came from other users (and not the server). Without this assumption, the server can perform a Sybil attack on the users in RoundShareKeys"
Basically assume there is some trustworthy entity that solves Sybil attacks. I don't think such an entity exists. So question is how they solve that in practice.
My stylistic criticism is that they portray white men in a demeaning way that they would never dare do to any other group.
edited to make a weaker claim