News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Must Defend Science in the Face of Political Attacks by 75dvtwin on Saturday May 18, 2019 @12:26AM (#19945602)
I think there are 4 categories of topics

1) ideological (including political (globa/local), or religious

2) technical

3) personal (meaning focus is, specifically, on subjective position)

4) moral (meaning, focus is on subjective, but relatable at a group/society/era level)

Problem is with ( 1 ), and may be ( 4 ).

My personal view, is that if HN is to allow new submissions where (1) and (4) are present. Those submissions should go through a different flow, than (2) and (3).

These submissions should be marked as such, then reviewed by a moderator, to see if it fits the broader category of HN-allowed submissions.

And then, if the submission passes moderation, the discussion on those posts cannot follow same upvote/downvote model as ( 2 ) or (3). Because regular upvote/downvote model puts at disadvantage minority view.

-- --

WRT your question > Let me ask you a question, though you don't have to answer it. Do you feel like HN is biased against the point of view you yourself favor

Yes, I think selection of submissions, downvotes and flags favors disproportionally to anti-Trump, anti-Brexit, anti-Kavanaugh, anti-male rhetoric.

I particular share a view of environment issues, though I favor non-global, trade-based solutions. So I, personally do remember incidents where my submissions or comments were downvoted on that topic.

Interestingly, on more political conservative forums, that I participate on -- when I argue a pro-environment position -- I get some pushback, sometime ridicule -- but my comments never 'grayed out' or flagged.

-- Sorry for a long, response. But yes. I favor particular ideology and moral stance. Everybody has those positions.

I also appreciate, particularly, flexibility of mind and personal ability to adjust to something different if circumstances or new information dictates that.

I have yet to find any discussion that would cause me a shift in my positions on (1) or (4). I suspect this is same with other people, but being tested by questions, or telling others what I think -- is engaging, nevertheless.

Another thing, I noticed, that I tend to use 'reciprocal' tone. So the actual tone would depend on some selection/aggregation of other folks tone.

My overall complaint, if I may call it that, is flagging/graying out expressions that are conservative-leaning.

There are no comments on this comment yet.