Re:Make users read before they vote
by crasshopper on Friday December 10, 2010 @06:56PM
(#1993688)
That's an excellent suggestion with different implications than mine.
Hiding / colouring the ^ would tell the users that they shouldn't be upvoting before they read.
But as you say, there are a variety of complicated mechanisms behind-the-scenes that could simply give low weight to votes by non-readers.
You could also mess with the time-mechanics of upvotes with various properties, with the goal of just killing happenstance cascade upvoting. And this could vary with site traffic.
However, there is always a danger to adding more knobs to tweak.
Re:Make users read before they vote
by zacharycohn on Friday December 10, 2010 @06:31PM
(#1993618)
The article linked above took me about 20 seconds to read...
I like the idea of a timer, but there's no way you can set a timer that will equate well to all the links submitted.
Yes and tweets have the same problem. A thorough fix would scrape the article and measure the length.
Re:Make users read before they vote
by crasshopper on Friday December 10, 2010 @07:03PM
(#1993710)
> tweets have the same problem
Can you explain what you mean?
Sometimes tweets show up as top stories on HN. A tweet takes a few seconds to read and vote on. So the timer idea would not allow tweet stories to get to the top unless the timer knew the story was a tweet.
But most stories are not tweets and not short, so should take over a minute to read.
Mechanisms are worth a try. Votes from people who haven't clicked the article should be weighted differently. Also worth trying is a timer after you click the article. If the user skims the article in 20 seconds, that vote should weigh less than a vote after several minutes.
Then see if weighing votes differently increases the quality of top stories.