News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Public's Dread of Nuclear Power Limits Its Deployment by pdonis on Thursday May 16, 2019 @06:41PM (#19934183)
> I also thought there were "no incidents".

You mention the San Onofre plant, but that was not a US Navy reactor, it was a commercial generating plant. I was specifically talking about US Navy reactors on ships and submarines.

I have not read the book you referenced, but I have added it to my reading list. It seems like it is focused on commercial nuclear plants.

> tell me that we know what we're doing and that we "know how to safely operate nuclear power plants" after reading things like

These are not errors that happened because nobody knows how to do these things correctly. They are errors that happened because technically ignorant managers and business people were making decisions they should not have been making. The US Navy's program solves that problem by not allowing technically ignorant people to be in decision making positions. And even technically non-ignorant people who make minor errors of judgment--far short of the kind illustrated in the incidents you mention--are fired and no longer allowed to operate the reactors, so they never reach the point where they can make a wrong decision that would have significant adverse consequences.

The reasons why civilian nuclear power in the US was never held to the same standards, again, are political, not technical. And it's also worth noting that no other energy source in the US gets held to such standards, even though all of them have caused far more harm than nuclear ever has.

> which newer designs do you mean?

Pebble bed reactors and small modular reactors, for example. But even a standard light water reactor can be passively safe against a TMI or Fukushima type scenario if the cooling system is designed to utilize natural circulation, which US Navy submarine reactors are (they do it in order to be quieter, since they don't require coolant pumps unless the sub is at high speed, but it also gives the passive safety benefit).

There are no comments on this comment yet.