News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by helveticaman on Saturday May 24, 2008 @11:40PM (#199320)
What's your stance on the question of race and intelligence? It's a hardball, but fits the bill as something that's hard to talk about.

If you determined that there were differences between races, and it was in the best interest of your children to discriminate against certain people, what would you tell them? Would you ever tell them to discriminate against other races if that was truly in their best interest?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Race_and_intelligence

Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by natrius on Sunday May 25, 2008 @12:24AM (#199334)
Even if there are differences between races in terms on intelligence, how could it ever be in their best interest to discriminate against certain groups of people? There is considerable overlap in the distributions of ability among races, so prejudging an individual based on their particular group's distribution doesn't ever make any sense.

If my hypothetical child asked about that, I would explain what we actually know about what causes differences in ability, such as socioeconomic factors.

Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by helveticaman on Sunday May 25, 2008 @01:07AM (#199349)
The general argument on race is ugly in many ways, but I think it serves as a good example of something that is controversial today, not 120 years ago. Whether racial differences exist and whether discrimination is useful in some cases is debatable. What's more important is whether you (I'm sorry about the ad hominem) would lie to your child about something as controversial as race just to be in sync with society.

I'm not saying (or rather, I don't want to say) that race exists and discrimination is good. But it's the closest argument we have to the evolution argument of days past.

Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by _h4xr on Sunday May 25, 2008 @01:01AM (#199347)
Even if there are differences between ages in terms of height, how could it ever be in my kid's best interest to think that the average six-year-old is taller than the average five-year-old, even though there are five-year-olds taller than individual six-year-olds? The overlap in these distributions is so considerable that Bayes' Theorem doesn't apply.
Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by yummyfajitas on Sunday May 25, 2008 @08:18AM (#199487)
Provided you believe that P(A | B) = P(A & B)/P(B), Bayes theorem always applies.
Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by _h4xr on Sunday May 25, 2008 @11:12AM (#199534)
I was making fun of the previous poster, who seems to be arguing that even if group A has an average IQ of 115 and group B has an average IQ of 70, there is overlap between their distributions and so it should be shocking to you that there are more A's with Nobel Prizes and more B's unemployed or in prison.
Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by natrius on Sunday May 25, 2008 @02:49PM (#199657)
It's not about having more or less of something. Discrimination implies an act of selection. That more A's have Nobel Prizes doesn't suggest that I should always pick A's over B's when I need an intelligent person.

Also, there are no racial groups for which your average IQs hold. My point is not just that there is any overlap, it's that there is considerable overlap, which renders discrimination based on race quite useless.

Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by _h4xr on Sunday May 25, 2008 @04:01PM (#199689)
Most racists I know of don't suggest that one should use race when other variables are available -- e.g. they don't say that a black guy in a suit is more dangerous than a white meth-head with a gun, even though statistically black people are more criminal, because intuitively the armed cracked-out guy is even more criminal. I don't see how knowing average IQs of different ethnic groups obligates you to make mistaken judgments by overemphasizing them -- are you worried that other people will make this elementary mistake?

Also, discrimination means being able to tell different things apart. A 'discriminating' taste in wine means knowing the difference between good wine and bad, not thinking that all the wine from region A is better than any wine from region B.

Ashkenazim and sub-Saharan Africans?

Again, with the 'some overlap renders it useless' argument. I still don't understand why you will not also educate your child against the dangers of thinking that age correlates with height, when everyone knows that there are ten-year-olds who all taller than particular nine-year-olds -- and that you can have arbitrarily narrow age groups that make the average difference far smaller than the difference within each group. Overlapping bell curves with different medians still have different medians, however much they overlap.

Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by natrius on Sunday May 25, 2008 @05:07PM (#199725)
My argument was in terms of real world situations in which it would be in someone's best interests to discriminate based on race. The point is that there are very few, if any, since there are other variables that are a far better proxy for intelligence than race due to the overlap in distributions. I wasn't trying to say that the overlap makes the medians irrelevant altogether; it just makes them irrelevant in almost any real situation.

The knowledge that the average ten-year old is taller than the average nine-year old is just as useless as knowing that the average Ashkenazi Jew has a higher IQ than the average sub-Saharan African.

Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by _h4xr on Sunday May 25, 2008 @05:46PM (#199747)
So are you arguing that it isn't useful to know about racial differences, even if they're true? I hear about them all the time! People wonder why there are so many black people in prison, or why there are so many Asians earning PhDs. Some people have good explanations for these phenomena. One problem with ignoring data about racial differences is that you end up being forced to argue that some races (or all races) are viciously racist -- that white folks want Africa to be a hellhole, and are willing to sacrifice all kinds of natural resources to keep it that way. The world makes more sense if people vary in abilities and tendencies, rather than being absolutely equal in every way, except that some people are evil.

You would really be indifferent between finding yourself in Boro Park or Bedford-Stuyvessant? I understand the rent is very cheap in the latter (I lived there a while). Bed-Stuy doesn't have sub-Saharan Africans (or if it does, they're very smart immigrants who are likely to move to a better neighborhood in a few years), but the people there are from roughly that group, plus some admixture.

Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by natrius on Sunday May 25, 2008 @06:08PM (#199761)
Actually, I think the reason so much attention is paid to which races earn PhDs or end up in jail is to find out how to increase the number of PhDs of other races or reduce the prison population of certain races. If those differences are caused by genetic differences, then there's nothing we can do to change that. There are other factors at work in both situations, like socioeconomic status and culture, which we can use to make everyone better off.

I think socioeconomic status is a better predictor of criminality than race. With that said, if I'm walking through an unfamiliar neighborhood, race is one of the few variables I have to work with. Unfortunately, in America, race is a moderately effective indicator of socioeconomic status, so I would use it as one factor in judging my safety. Even then, I usually use clothes and appearance rather than race to judge one's propensity for crime.

This is actually a more interesting problem in terms of what to tell children than racial differences in intelligence. I think by the time they're old enough to be somewhere without adult supervision, they are able to determine what looks like a poor area or poor person and act accordingly. I can see the logic that would lead someone to tell their kids to use race as such a proxy instead, but the consequences of doing so make it not worth the negligible increase in safety in my opinion.

Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by _h4xr on Sunday May 25, 2008 @11:47PM (#199946)
Actually, race is the single best predictor of how much crime to expect in a given area. Besides population already in prison, at least.

I think it's a red herring to ask why we're collecting the data in order to decide whether or not the data are accurate.

Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by natrius on Monday May 26, 2008 @12:09AM (#199963)
Really? That would be interesting data to look at. Do you have a source?

I don't care why we're collecting the data, and I was assuming the data was accurate. I'm just saying that as far as genetic differences are a factor in the data, there's nothing we can do about it or with it, so it's useless.

Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by mynameishere on Sunday May 25, 2008 @02:49AM (#199403)
race and intelligence?

I don't think this subject comes up very often with small children. "Discrimination" is just a probabilistic decision made wherever imperfect knowledge exists. That is, you look at the demographics of a neighborhood before moving there, knowing full well that it's not an ideal measure. Again, what can children do about such a thing?

The OP seemed to be setting up a scenario in which his parents said, "...and others disagree" and so made themselves seem "truthful". That's halfway to getting to the real truth which is, "We ourselves are completely without a clue, but prefer Yahweh over Ganesh because an elephant head is bullcrap a mite too obvious for our tastes. Others disagree."

The real secret is that truth doesn't matter too much unless it involves something that can damage you. God, it just so happens, is not among the things that can damage you. And so, feel free to believe whatever you want.

Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by lisper on Sunday May 25, 2008 @03:51AM (#199419)
> If you determined that there were differences between races, and it was in the best interest of your children to discriminate against certain people, what would you tell them?

I would tell them to beware of plausible-sounding theories. And I'd have them read this:

http://rondam.blogspot.com/2007/11/science-103-virtue-of-sim...

Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by maxklein on Sunday May 25, 2008 @04:47AM (#199442)
This is a classic case of the harm that not lying to your children can cause. The things my parents told me when I was young shaped a large part of my world view. If you were a racist, enough of that would seep through to influence your child. If you tried to explain bell curves and so on, and you believed that white people were more clever than black people, your child would grasp the subtext of what you are saying.

The best thing to do is to not pre-infect your child with your own personal notions on controversial topics till he is equipped to think independently about them.

Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by thwarted on Sunday May 25, 2008 @05:01PM (#199720)
Which topics qualify as controversial is itself something that there can be disagreement on. Race and intelligence is one of them. The parent who purposely imparts to their child a race preference does not believe that racism is a controversial topic.
Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by _h4xr on Sunday May 25, 2008 @01:45AM (#199370)
Parents who think this way probably sound like regular parents, but more succinct. They have one more tool to identify harmful people and situations, and they don't have to rely on proxies ("He's from a bad neighborhood") to say what they mean.
Re:Telling our children the truth: response to Paul Graham by Tichy on Sunday May 25, 2008 @04:28AM (#199436)
Presumably people could/would tell kids what they believe themselves, or if they don't have a clue, they could tell their kids that they don't have a clue.