News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Public's Dread of Nuclear Power Limits Its Deployment by gwbas1c on Thursday May 16, 2019 @03:07PM (#19931984)
As a huge renewable energy fan, I need to point out that your viewpoint is factually incorrect.

For example: I built a very low carbon home a year ago, with giant solar panels sized to charge two electric cars, and to heat the house with heat pumps.

I live in the Northeast US, where it gets cold in the winter. The reason why it gets cold in the winter is because the days are very short.

Because the days are shorter in the winter, the solar panels do not generate enough electricity to heat the house, so I end up using a lot of grid electricity in December and January.

And, what really stinks is that April was unusually cloudy this year. So, when I should have generated excess, I ended up pulling from the grid.

In contrast, I have a lot of excess power in the summer when the days are long. (Air conditioning doesn't use as much electricity as heating.)

Now, comes the facts:

We don't have technology that can store the energy that I generate in the summer for use in the winter. Batteries are great for short term storage: Charge at noon when the panels generate the most power, discharge at night.

Even worse, my very expensive Powerwall can't run my heat pump, nor could it hold enough charge to heat my home overnight. Even if I doubled my panels and had a few more Powerwalls, I'd need to pull from the grid in some of the rather bad cold snaps we had this winter.

This is why people say that Nuclear can solve the problem now. Renewables are a great long-term solution, but we still need a lot of R&D to solve the problem of storing energy in the summer for use in the winter. In contrast, the nuclear power plant 15 miles from my home can run my heat pump in the dead of winter, without requiring any new storage technology.

Re:Public's Dread of Nuclear Power Limits Its Deployment by dv_dt on Thursday May 16, 2019 @03:22PM (#19932144)
I agree that storage really isn't up to seasonal demand variation yet. But I also don't think we should take out current nuclear and should run current plants to end of life - even extending their life where practical. But I strongly think that project success/completion data points to new nuclear plants being a poor investment financially and time wise for carbon suppression vs our other options.

I am a bit curious why running a wood fired stove in the winter doesn't meet your heating needs in a modern well-insulated low carbon home? We need a set of different, possibly non-uniform solutions. For heat, why not store power by growing forests in the spring/summer, and burning wood in the winter? Not high-tech I know, but some of the automatic pellet feed systems are very low touch.

Re:Public's Dread of Nuclear Power Limits Its Deployment by Loughla on Thursday May 16, 2019 @03:42PM (#19932331)
>why not store power by growing forests in the spring/summer, and burning wood in the winter?

I honestly don't mean for this to be snarky, but I know it's going to sound like it is.

(1) How much property do you believe one home would take to heat using trees?

(2) How quickly do you think trees can grow, barring some horrific invasive species?

(3) Why do you think we moved away from this model in the past?

Spoiler, I know these answers for my area of the US (Northern Midwest), I'm just fascinated to see why you would ask that question. Because it's ridiculous as a solution.

Re:Public's Dread of Nuclear Power Limits Its Deployment by cygx on Thursday May 16, 2019 @04:37PM (#19932931)
Note that this is not a hypothetical situation: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pellet_fuel
Re:Public's Dread of Nuclear Power Limits Its Deployment by Loughla on Thursday May 16, 2019 @04:51PM (#19933070)
I'm aware of pellet burning stoves. There are also smoke recyclers and burners for home stoves which make them even more efficient.

But in what way are those carbon neutral? (which is what I thought was the point of this entire thing)

And that doesn't answer my questions.

Re:Public's Dread of Nuclear Power Limits Its Deployment by cygx on Thursday May 16, 2019 @05:08PM (#19933250)
And that doesn't answer my questions.

It wasn't supposed to do so, but raise awareness that your questions are already highly relevant in the present and not just a hypothetical future: The UK consumes something on the order of 8 million tons of wood pellets per year.

The carbon footprint depends on the source of the wood (eg replacing naturally grown with farmed trees is not a carbon neutral activity). Shipping has to be considered as well.

Uninformed layperson that I am, I'd guess power-to-gas would be a superior solution, but it's pretty expensive right now...

Re:Public's Dread of Nuclear Power Limits Its Deployment by dv_dt on Thursday May 16, 2019 @05:54PM (#19933764)
So what are the numbers for the Northern Midwest, and why are they ridiculous? If there's a report link that break down the model, I love that kind of reading.
Re:Public's Dread of Nuclear Power Limits Its Deployment by pfdietz on Friday May 17, 2019 @07:53AM (#19938619)
A study found that to 70% renewable penetration in Minnesota, it's cheaper to just overinstall solar and curtail when it produces too much, rather than add storage.

https://www.utilitydive.com/news/minnesota-study-finds-it-ch...

In that scenario, there will be strong incentive to find uses for the low capacity factor very cheap (nearly free) power the curtailment implies. For example, very cheap mediocre efficiency membraneless electrolyzers could make hydrogen. Also in that scenario, there is no place for high capital cost baseload sources, as the price will crash too often for them to be profitable.

Re:Public's Dread of Nuclear Power Limits Its Deployment by jacquesm on Thursday May 16, 2019 @03:11PM (#19932026)
It sounds to me like maybe you should consider a hybrid of solar and wind power. When I lived in Northern Ontario (where winters are brutally cold) whenever we did not have sun we had plenty of wind. Once the wind generator was up we never needed outside power (in our case: a generator).