Re:I froze the salaries of my executive team to benefit othe...
by conanbatt on Thursday May 16, 2019 @11:56AM
(#19930146)
> Economics is amoral
Such a thing does not exist. It is the study of exchange between individuals, any model that brings down morality to 0 will not be useful, practical or a applicable.
There is a reason why the most iconic political economists were all philosophers!
Re:I froze the salaries of my executive team to benefit othe...
by beat on Thursday May 16, 2019 @12:29PM
(#19930429)
When you buy something from Amazon, is it an exchange between individuals? When you get a paycheck from a corporate employer, is it an exchange between individuals? No, that makes no sense. It's an exchange between an individual and an abstract legal/financial entity that engages in economic activity, but is in no rational way a human being. And what about B2B exchange? Clearly, it's economics, but when Wal-Mart buys a wholesale lot of shampoo from Proctor & Gamble, it is absurd to think of that as "between individuals".
Re:I froze the salaries of my executive team to benefit othe...
by conanbatt on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:42PM
(#19931684)
> When you buy something from Amazon, is it an exchange between individuals?
Yes. You exchange your labor, divided into an unseen number of customers for another one's labor, divided into an unseen number of customers.
Remove individual interactions and see everything disappear. Its the building block of society.
Re:I froze the salaries of my executive team to benefit othe...
by beat on Thursday May 16, 2019 @05:05PM
(#19933210)
Ok, even if you take humans as the motivating agent... how does it become a moral act? How is an exchange of money for goods/services an inherent good, or an inherent evil for that matter?
Without intelligence guiding them, such systems can easily destroy themselves with feedback loops. Power differentials etc, in an amoral environment, lead to low-level employees getting screwed and owners/upper management getting rich. This feedback loop can eventually destroy a company, or a society.
So what I find hard to understand isn't that employees go along with this system that screws them (they need to eat, y'know?), but rather that they think it's good, that it's what's best for everyone, that maximized profits will be equitably distributed. We have an angry, populist working class that has completely accepted the systematic inequalities of neoliberal-flavored capitalism, and the socialist welfare-state hacks that come with it mostly to keep the whole thing from self-destructing this year at least. They're mad they're getting screwed, but think their bosses are completely right to screw them.
It's really hard to grok that.