News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Incognito no more: Publishers close loopholes as paywall ... by hamilyon2 on Thursday May 16, 2019 @12:55AM (#19926241)
Wait, what? Is content shadowing now ok with Google?

I always thought that content presented to Google bot should be very very close to what user see when they click link. And if not, Google penalize website hard. Has that changed?

I mean, if rule still stands, than news websites will show up in search results with keywords "subscription" and "article". Instead of "USA" and "brexit".

If content shadowing is ok now, that gives spammers a free ride.

Re:Incognito no more: Publishers close loopholes as paywall ... by akersten on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:11AM (#19926311)
> Wait, what? Is content shadowing now ok with Google?

It goes by a different name, but yes - the policy ended according to the article:

> Google’s ending of first-click free now means that subscription publishers can still appear in Google search results without offering access.

Kind of a shame. I remember my frustrations in the mid-2000's of search results riddled with this dark pattern in the form of ExpertsExchange and Quora results.

Re:Incognito no more: Publishers close loopholes as paywall ... by kranner on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:30AM (#19926399)
Kind of an aside, but on ExpertsExchange you simply had to scroll down past the blurred div to see the full content.
Re:Incognito no more: Publishers close loopholes as paywall ... by naner on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:39AM (#19926432)
That was their adaptation to Google's rules. Initially answers were behind a paywall.
Re:Incognito no more: Publishers close loopholes as paywall ... by jacquesm on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:04AM (#19926283)
This hasn't been the case for years if you're a big name. Small fry lives by different rules than the Washington Post or the San Francisco Chronicle.
Re:Incognito no more: Publishers close loopholes as paywall ... by luckylion on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:30AM (#19926678)
Springer (the science publisher, not the German trash media company) has done that since at least 10 years. They'd send the full text PDF to Google and the abstract & buy option as HTML to users. Google doesn't care.
Re:Incognito no more: Publishers close loopholes as paywall ... by sfifs on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:44AM (#19926728)
I think you need to think through objectives and motivations rather than approach policies as if they were if-then-else conditions.

Objective of Google is to maximize their search revenue. The biggest driver of revenue is users. More users use Google search more often if it shows them relevant high quality content more often and they're satisfied after clicking through and reading.

Big name famous publishers usually produce high quality content. Try want traffic and they also want to monetize via subscriptions. So naturally there's a win win for Google to show high quality results in spite of paywall and find a way to work together.

Re:Incognito no more: Publishers close loopholes as paywall ... by Nextgrid on Thursday May 16, 2019 @07:14AM (#19927895)
I’m not sure it’s a win-win though. Most users don’t want to pay for anything. If they get used to not being able to access major news search results they’ll simply stop searching for news or at least not click on the publishers they remember having a paywall.
Re:Incognito no more: Publishers close loopholes as paywall ... by lysp on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:10AM (#19926305)
It is a constant annoyance to me when my mobile google app suggests "interesting stories" to me which end up being paywall locked.
Re:Incognito no more: Publishers close loopholes as paywall ... by a3n on Thursday May 16, 2019 @01:42AM (#19926445)
Google's just trying to help their customers succeed.
Re:Incognito no more: Publishers close loopholes as paywall ... by ssss11 on Thursday May 16, 2019 @05:43AM (#19927516)
Maybe google doesn’t like their search market dominance