News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fundamental design principles for non-designers by TeMPOraL on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @02:12PM (#19922127)
I like those and generally agree, though I'd change one thing: if you're designing something that's meant to be used - as opposed to just looking pretty - ignore advice about maximizing negative space. Just fit all the information your users need at a given moment on the screen. Information density is your friend, scrolling isn't.

(Of course, the section "Reduce Visual Noise" still applies.)

Re:Fundamental design principles for non-designers by cle on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @03:10PM (#19922660)
I strongly agree with this. From TFA:

> Putting too many elements into a limited amount of space is like trying to listen to three different songs at once. It’s hard to understand what is being said.

In some situations, putting more information on the screen, parseable without scrolling, helps tell the right kind of story (for example, when comparing a bunch of options). So I think this advice is only halfway there:

> give your designs as much negative space as you possibly can, to declutter them and make their meaning more obvious.

Should also include "Don't add so much negative space that cohesiveness is lost."

Re:Fundamental design principles for non-designers by mhink on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @08:02PM (#19924976)
Although I'm an engineer and not a designer, I think it's fair to point out that this is article is primarily about visual design, which is only one aspect of the design of the overall user experience. There's a phrase I've heard, "information architecture", which roughly seems to mean "how the layout and presentation help the user process the information being presented". With this in mind, I think a lot of folks (both designers and engineers) conflate the two sometimes.

Another thing: I suspect that information-dense visuals are sort of like highly-performant software: hard to design, harder to implement, and much harder to change once you've gone to all the trouble of squeezing out every possible optimization. As advice for beginners, it seems fine to say "add more negative space", just like we tell junior engineers to "avoid premature optimization", because the ability to recognize when those optimizations are needed goes hand-in-hand with the ability to actually do them right.

Re:Fundamental design principles for non-designers by p1necone on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @09:01PM (#19925238)
Is conflating them the wrong thing to do? Surely you're never working on just one in isolation?
Re:Fundamental design principles for non-designers by seanmcdirmid on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @02:49PM (#19922473)
Negative space is a usability, not just aesthetic, concern. Judicious use can reduce confusion and stress, while promoting focus.

Scrolling is sometimes necessary to avoid a screen that has too much going on.

Re:Fundamental design principles for non-designers by TeMPOraL on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @03:08PM (#19922644)
True, but I believe current design trends are biased way too much towards negative space. Assuming you follow the "Reduce Visual Noise" advice, and proximity principle, and stick to displaying information relevant to the task at hand (as opposed to displaying everything), it's really hard to overload a screen with data. Haven't seen that done in software.
Re:Fundamental design principles for non-designers by digaozao on Thursday May 16, 2019 @06:05AM (#19927607)
Counter example. I worked with software looking like this more than one time: https://images.app.goo.gl/Pvpo1xhv2HqKJCuW8
Re:Fundamental design principles for non-designers by TeMPOraL on Thursday May 16, 2019 @06:49AM (#19927767)
Interesting example. That's what I would call quite good design. Bear with me.

Yes, it does look overwhelming on first impression. But that's just a first impression. Look at it more closely.

What this software implements is a multi-step pipe, where each step is configurable. Every UI element you see represents a useful feature in minimal way. They're all, arguably, essential complexity of the task. The steps are both ordered spatially and explicitly numbered. They can be configured both by mouse and by keyboard. You have an interactive live preview at the top, telling you what the current configuration will change and how. Most important here, however, is that you always see the entire configuration. There are no hidden dialogs, no steps or tabs - what you see on the screen is what's going to be done to the data.

Is it pretty? Not really, though I'd say they've done a good job given the constraints of native Windows UI. Is it useful? You bet. Is it hard to learn? Not really (as long as you speak English). I assume there's a manual attached to the program that will at least guide less tech-savvy people towards basics of regular expressions, but beyond that, the software seems to support both manual-based and interactive "trial&error" learning.

In all honesty, this is an extreme case of what I call UI optimized for utility. Good POS software looks like that. Good inventory management software looks like that. This kind of design is appreciated by people who have to work with an application frequently - e.g. as a part of their dayjob - because it saves time while playing into strengths of human perception.

I want more software to look like that.

Re:Fundamental design principles for non-designers by genezeta on Thursday May 16, 2019 @02:56AM (#19926764)
I think, as others have already mentioned, it's not all one way or the other. Different situations require different approaches.

In general, being aware and correctly using negative/white space is a good thing. The problem is that the article doesn't actually explain this part correctly. To make things worse, the example chosen has an extremely narrow focus.

The key point to learn is that white space can produce layout as much as elements do. This is, in fact, already explained then talking about proximity. You can't really establish proximity if you don't establish separation, so you can't produce a clear layout if you don't keep some spaces "empty". And so, yes, it shouldn't be about maximizing white space, but about using it correctly and making it part of your layout.

Generally, the rule with white space is not about maximizing but this one: Give an element as much white space as the difference in importance of the element over its surroundings. That is, if an element is differentially more important, it should have more white space around it.

So if you only have one very important element and some others much less so, then sure, that element will take over a large amount of its surrounding space and that should be kept empty. This is the example shown in the article, where there is only one important element. In the case you mention, in an information dense layout, you tend to have numbers of elements of similar importance, and so they will have to share white space and produce a more compact -dense- layout.

Re:Fundamental design principles for non-designers by TeMPOraL on Thursday May 16, 2019 @03:14AM (#19926844)
The problem with this advice is that whitespace separation is relative (e.g. this element is 2x important, so it's separated by 2x whitespace). People end up picking too big base whitespace value.

> The key point to learn is that white space can produce layout as much as elements do.

Trick is, you can invert that too. While this won't win you a design advice this decade, it's equally possible to use backgrounds or borders to group and separate elements. It's how we did this back before negative space became fashionable, and it supports greater information density.

Re:Fundamental design principles for non-designers by genezeta on Thursday May 16, 2019 @03:42AM (#19926955)
Yes, I did not mean my comment as anything more than "it is a tool; sometimes it's a good tool; learn to use it". Or as saying that while "maximize white space" is not a good advice, saying one should completely ignore it is also not such a good idea.

Other than that, I never suggested any precise relation such as 2x important -> 2x space.

Re:Fundamental design principles for non-designers by news_to_me on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @02:37PM (#19922378)
There's a balance. Usability and "looking pretty" aren't opposites. Of course, there's often trade-offs involved. Maybe "maximizing" is the wrong idea though.
Re:Fundamental design principles for non-designers by TeMPOraL on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @03:12PM (#19922689)
They aren't opposites, but they aren't orthogonal either. Past some point, you have to choose one over the other. I think most designs are far from that point, though - they could easily improve information density by an order of magnitude while still remaining pretty.
Re:Fundamental design principles for non-designers by itronitron on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @03:50PM (#19923056)
It becomes a lot harder to get it right as more visual information is added. Tufte is an excellent source for design guidelines on information density. It is important to keep in mind however that Tufte focuses primarily on static visual representations that people can spend time on, and that do not update.
Re:Fundamental design principles for non-designers by xeeeeeeeeeeenu on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @03:45PM (#19923015)
>ignore advice about maximizing negative space.

I think it's a spectrum. On one end there are Windows 10 UWP applications which have absurd amounts of negative space, while on the other end there's e.g. Plasma with its claustrophobic, crowded UI. Both result in terrible UX (although, to be fair, UWP is much worse), so the sweet point in somewhere in the middle of that spectrum.

Re:Fundamental design principles for non-designers by Iv on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @11:41PM (#19925959)
So much this.

Information density goes down quicker than my screens grow in size. Now on a typical chat platform I can see less of a discussion than in a typical 1990 IRC client.

If the point of your site is to transmit text information, negative space is something you should avoid. One pixel can be enough there.

Re:Fundamental design principles for non-designers by anthonyshort on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @07:04PM (#19924651)
Every design is meant to be used. The amount of space needed is relative to the problem.
Re:Fundamental design principles for non-designers by TeMPOraL on Thursday May 16, 2019 @03:20AM (#19926862)
No, some designs are meant to use you - think advertising, or applications that look "clean" and "ordered" to drive sales.

Even the designs meant to be used can support or hinder their intended use. Abuse of negative space is one example of hindering the use - by requiring users to scroll more than they should, or precluding them from visual comparison because compared elements can never fit on the screen together.