Re:FCC Chairman Proposes Robocall Blocking by Default
by SpicyLemonZest on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @12:17PM
(#19920902)
I'm not sure I agree it's dysfunctional. "We're going to block some people off from the phone lines because we don't think they ought to be making calls" is exactly the kind of policy that should be heavily scrutinized.
Re:FCC Chairman Proposes Robocall Blocking by Default
by philipov on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @12:26PM
(#19921001)
It could be dysfunctional if the application of that heavy scrutiny is overwhelmingly biased towards a particular interest rather than being applied uniformly. Complaints of dysfunction aren't based on disputes of principle, but anger at their implementation.
Re:FCC Chairman Proposes Robocall Blocking by Default
by mathnmusic on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @12:27PM
(#19921012)
That policy wouldn't be about blocking people from making calls. It'd be about allowing TOOLS that let USERS block unwanted calls.
Re:FCC Chairman Proposes Robocall Blocking by Default
by arebop on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @12:35PM
(#19921113)
It says it is about tools that "allow phone companies to block unwanted calls" (emphasis mine). So the one wielding the tool is the phone company. It's unclear whether users can opt out of the default. It's also unclear whether "unwanted" is defined with respect to the user or the company.
Re:FCC Chairman Proposes Robocall Blocking by Default
by jessriedel on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @03:08PM
(#19922646)
If it takes a decade and you wait until 50% of phone calls are spam, it's dysfunctional. Glacial speed is not the same as careful scrutiny.
You either need to update regulations on a fast time scale, or a way to encourage actual competition (so the heavy anti-trust-like regulations aren't required). Otherwise, you've just given up on there ever being meaningful progress/innovation in the industry.
Is this really true? How absolutely dysfunctional things must be.