News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are the American people obsolete? by jdietrich on Friday December 10, 2010 @10:25AM (#1991876)
It is worth remembering that the average American consumes an exceptional amount of resources. Compared even to the relatively profligate Europeans, the average American consumes twice as much energy, twice as much water and lives on more than twice as much land. The disparity with even wealthy urban Chinese or Indians is greater still.

This lifestyle has in part been justified by the very high historical levels of American productivity, but it is clear that American productivity is not increasing at nearly the rate of that in emerging markets.

We are left with an obvious conclusion - as a factor of production, American citizens continue to be very resource-intensive, but are becoming comparatively less productive.

It seems to me that America is unique in a culture that sees consumption of scarce resources as tantamount to a human right. Much of the cultural divide in the US seems to rest on this basic notion. Many political issues in the US are really debates about resources that no-one seems prepared to engage with - the US healthcare debate ought to be a debate about why Americans spend such incredible sums on medicine, but is instead primarily a debate about what kind of accounting we use to pay those incredible sums.

The idea of what it means to be American is obsolete. The sprawling suburb, the hour-long commute, the SUV, the McMansion, all artifacts of an empire in terminal decline. American citizens simply cannot consume such vast resources if they do not have the productivity to match. I see every reason why Chinese and Indian productivity will continue to rise, but little reason why American productivity would suddenly rally. The American people are left with an obvious choice - produce more or consume less.

Re:Are the American people obsolete? by allenp on Friday December 10, 2010 @10:32AM (#1991900)
I don't really see why the rate of productivity should matter as much as the absolute value of productivity in regards to distribution of wealth.

I agree the American suburban lifestyle is and will continue to decline as it just simply is not sustainable. These will be the new ghettos as more and more poor are pushed out of the cities into the now decaying suburbs.

As to why American productivity would rally, I can only imagine vast advances from nano and bio-tech and machines that build other machines.

Re:Are the American people obsolete? by nickpinkston on Friday December 10, 2010 @12:15PM (#1992303)
Well, to your first point, I'd say that productivity in relative terms is a more useful measure in this case because that's generally where the best investments are to made - if we're sticking with the "investors don't need america" part.

The issue with using absolute productivity in a global world is that comparative advantage in production (i.e. higher productivity growth, and with it higher real incomes in the developing world) are the driver for lifestyle.

Think of it this way: if others are wealthier, they'll put upward price pressure on supply side of goods that American's buy (look at copper for example) - while at the same time American productivity (vis-a-vis real income) decreases (or at least remains flat) make these goods less affordable from the demand side.

This means lifestyle, even with a fixed absolute productiviy, will decrease.

Re:Are the American people obsolete? by jordan0day on Friday December 10, 2010 @10:45AM (#1991954)
As long as it's the rich who have the money to pay for increasingly expensive resources like gas, what's their motivation for moving away from the suburbs?
Re:Are the American people obsolete? by rbranson on Friday December 10, 2010 @11:54AM (#1992228)
There aren't enough rich people to sustain the suburbs. I think what these people are talking about is the suburban middle-class entitlement mentality. The vast majority of middle-class americans live in suburbs and subscribe to the philosophy that they are compelled to consume as many resources as allowed by their bank account and/or credit cards. Frugalness, philanthropy, and community are not mainstream American values.
Re:Are the American people obsolete? by orangecat on Friday December 10, 2010 @01:09PM (#1992528)
Frugalness, philanthropy, and community are not mainstream American values.

US citizens give more in private charity than anyone else, both in absolute terms and GDP percentage: http://www.jonholato.com/2007/06/26/us-more-charitable-than-...

Re:Are the American people obsolete? by rbranson on Friday December 10, 2010 @01:40PM (#1992647)
If you consider any donation to a non-profit as charity, then sure. The article you linked uses a very loose definition of charity: any discretionary income received by non-profit entities. This covers pretty much all donations given to religious institutions (which covers 32%, by far the largest slice of the pie) and a huge amount of money given to educational institutions (which came in second place with 14%). There's very little charitable about the vast majority of modern churches and educational institutions (specifically private colleges and grade schools).

I view charity as giving money to an organization from which you receive no benefit. This pretty much wipes out the majority of US "charity."

Re:Are the American people obsolete? by cma on Friday December 10, 2010 @11:43PM (#1994191)
GDP in America is inflated with more useless things that net each other out (say, two competing marketing campaigns for different brands of bleach) than GDP anywhere else.
Re:Are the American people obsolete? by grav1tas on Friday December 10, 2010 @01:23PM (#1992578)
I think American values are an evolving thing across generations. The baby boomers grew up in a time where getting a home and all its effects were the thing to do because people were moving to a time of common homeownership. The boomlets grew up in a world where everybody already has homes, and it's hard (I think) to actualize yourself by doing exactly what your parents did. I think we're already experiencing somewhat of a shift to more abstract forms of actualization and values in younger generations. While I'm not trying to plug a politician here, I think the way President Obama's election campaign resonated with so many young people is some evidence to this effect. Some of these values may be what you consider not mainstream now, but give 20-30 years, they might be more prevalent again.
Re:Are the American people obsolete? by rbranson on Friday December 10, 2010 @01:43PM (#1992656)
I certainly hope so. The entitlement mentality of most boomers and their children is shocking to me sometimes.
Re:Are the American people obsolete? by rshigeta on Friday December 10, 2010 @10:38AM (#1991923)
I sadly have to agree with jd. Another way of seeing the article is that americans no longer contribute enough skills effort,value to the new economy to justify their lifestyle and that they should leverage taxes on the wealthy to compensate for that. I'm not rich, but I can see why this is not a winning proposition long term.
Re:Are the American people obsolete? by Kaizyn on Friday December 10, 2010 @12:08PM (#1992273)
All it would take to 'fix' our economic woes would be to reindustrialize. Coupled with high import tarrifs - in the range of 30-60% as was set historically during the periods of growth in the US, it wouldn't take long to restore the US 'productivity' and industrial output. It would mean that the large profit-seeking organizations in the US would make less money over time, but it would be better for the average American workers.
Re:Are the American people obsolete? by yummyfajitas on Friday December 10, 2010 @12:22PM (#1992332)
Unless you are referring to the recent recession (from which the graphs indicate we are recovering), we never de-industrialized. Our industrial output is higher than ever before.

http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/INDPRO

http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/IPMAN

Re:Are the American people obsolete? by pohl on Friday December 10, 2010 @01:22PM (#1992572)
I wonder what those graphs would look like when normalized by the growth in total GDP over time. (I took 're-industrialize' to mean as a percentage of output).
Re:Are the American people obsolete? by yummyfajitas on Friday December 10, 2010 @01:48PM (#1992671)
Why wonder when you can use the search box?

http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/GDPC96

They both increased by about 6.5x from 1950 to 2007.

Of course, I'm also not sure why the growth of non-industrial sectors of the economy is a bad thing, or represents a decline at all. I've learned a bit of martial arts over the past year or two - does that mean I need to "re-computerize" my skillset?

Re:Are the American people obsolete? by pohl on Friday December 10, 2010 @02:16PM (#1992764)
I'm no economist, but I believe the concern over manufacturing continuing to shrink as a percentage of U.S. economic activity comes from the question of whether the segments that are replacing it are things that bring money into the national economy. Do service sector jobs represent exportable economic activity? Are the sectors that replace manufacturing easily outsourced?

I think the issue is a little too complex than for a single rising trend-line to put us at ease.

Re:Are the American people obsolete? by cdavid on Friday December 10, 2010 @07:57PM (#1993805)
I don't know the situation in the US, but in France, most shrinkage of the industrial sector is due to outsourcing within the same country. For example, car manufacturers did almost everything by themselves 30 years ago in France, and they know depend a lot on "equipementier" (not sure what the right English translation would be - this refers to companies like Faurecia, which make seat, etc...). Those are counted as services, not industries. Yet, they build exactly the same thing.

This has been studied extensively in France, I would be surprised if it were not the case in the US as well.

Re:Are the American people obsolete? by yummyfajitas on Friday December 10, 2010 @02:52PM (#1992904)
...whether the segments that are replacing it...

No sector has "replaced" manufacturing. Some sectors of the economy may have grown faster, but manufacturing has also grown.

It's much the same with skills. My martial arts skills have grown more quickly than my computer skills recently, but I've become more skilled at both programming and fighting. Our economy provides both manufactured goods and massages - historically it only produced the former. That's a good thing.

Re:Are the American people obsolete? by pohl on Friday December 10, 2010 @03:43PM (#1993093)
No sector has "replaced" manufacturing.

That's not true if you think structurally, as a percentage of the whole.

The analogy to skills is dubious. A closer parallel might be the time you spend at a given activity. If you become obsessed with your martial arts, and you quit your job without finding a way to make your kata profitable, then you would have need to worry about your finances, yes?

Re:Are the American people obsolete? by yummyfajitas on Friday December 10, 2010 @03:55PM (#1993138)
That clearly has not occurred, since (let me point this out one more time) we manufacture more now than ever before.

But lets run with your time analogy. We became more productive at manufacturing, and we now manufacture more stuff with less human input. Humans have been freed up to perform other useful work (services).

It's kind of like me becoming really good at my job, finishing all my work by Tuesday night, getting a pay raise, and then spending Wed-Fri at a second job (e.g., martial arts instructor). Oh noes! I hope this never happens to me!

Re:Are the American people obsolete? by pohl on Friday December 10, 2010 @05:52PM (#1993523)
we manufacture more now than ever before

I don't understand how you can expect this statement to carry your thesis in isolation.

Let's say you earn more money in your job than you ever have before.

Does that mean you're running "in the black"? No, because you might have also increased your expenditures out of proportion with your increase in income.

It's not enough to observe that manufacturing has increased, for imagine a country with ever-increasing manufacturing but declining exports of manufactured goods. Clearly it's possible for your observation to be true whilst not indicating a strong economy.

Again, I'm no economist, but I know enough to distrust one Pollyanna graph when I see one.

Re:Are the American people obsolete? by eru on Saturday December 11, 2010 @11:03AM (#1995034)
Sounds like mercantilism.
Re:Are the American people obsolete? by sudont on Friday December 10, 2010 @12:22PM (#1992328)
"Have you no shame?" I bet you do, and everyone else here too.

The problem is that American executives don't.

Look at the pay gap between American and European or Japanese executives: 2x European executives, 4x for the Japanese and Koreans. http://www.nytimes.com/2007/02/18/world/americas/18iht-lette...

While there's some fiscal rules in place to benefit society in those countries, the main cause of this disparity is purely greed in American executives. With the way that the current top players are willing to sit on production startups, there's no way to reindustrialize without complete societal change. Namely, reducing everyone's consumption and increasing the uptake of domestically produced, high-quality and long-lasting goods.

Since the current system favors shameless outsourcing and cheap goods, your simple, effective plan is completely stonewalled.

Re:Are the American people obsolete? by civilian on Friday December 10, 2010 @01:21PM (#1992566)
If we passed high import tariffs then other nations would pass reactionary import tariffs and make it harder for our goods to be sold overseas. In general, it would lower trade. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smoot%E2%80%93Hawley_Tariff_Act
Re:Are the American people obsolete? by eru on Saturday December 11, 2010 @11:02AM (#1995031)
You don't need the reaction argument. High tariffs are bad, no matter if the other guys decides to also bang their head against the wall or not.
Re:Are the American people obsolete? by india on Friday December 10, 2010 @02:33PM (#1992818)
Robots.

(Seriously, that productivity multiplier is not more than a decade away. Humanoid and mostly remotely controlled. Americans will put these to a far greater effect than Indians or Chinese.)