News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla crashes into wall during auto-park, Tesla: Beta fea... by heyyyouu on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @07:05PM (#19914705)
What I don't understand (and maybe I'm just naive) is how it's legal to test a so-called "beta feature" -- which, if it fails, clearly can be dangerous (lucky no one was hurt) -- on customers in a live environment, vs using its own test drivers at the very least? I can't imagine this being legal with any other form of transportation (or just large equipment; they don't even sell lightbulbs that aren't CE certified).
Re:Tesla crashes into wall during auto-park, Tesla: Beta fea... by SilasX on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @08:06PM (#19915110)
Yeah, you'll notice that aviation industry doesn't have an equivalent.

Which is not to say that none of their new features fail catastrophically -- as we were reminded recently by the 300 MAX -- but they don't consider this a valid defense.

Re:Tesla crashes into wall during auto-park, Tesla: Beta fea... by TheAdamist on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @07:25AM (#19918310)
the auto industry doesn't have this equivalent either, its just tesla. They'll eventually just claim everything is beta and take no responsibility for anything not working.
Re:Tesla crashes into wall during auto-park, Tesla: Beta fea... by surrealize on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @01:20AM (#19916624)
Of course Tesla tests things itself with its own drivers. What they can't do is replicate every single one of the unusual corner cases that people encounter in the real world.
Re:Tesla crashes into wall during auto-park, Tesla: Beta fea... by hjk05 on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @01:43AM (#19916737)
Sure, but that’s true of all companies. Imagine a drug company put a drug on the market that might kill your or leave you crippled if you don’t match the results they had on their 3 test patients, and them telling you “That’s on you, the drug is a beta”.
Re:Tesla crashes into wall during auto-park, Tesla: Beta fea... by kruczek on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @04:30AM (#19917415)
That's a bad example, because drugs typically have all kinds of warnings about negative effects. They certainly test on more than 3 patients, and they won't tell you the drug is a beta, but I'm sure they will still claim they are not responsible, because they warned you about very small chance of failure.
Re:Tesla crashes into wall during auto-park, Tesla: Beta fea... by surrealize on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @09:31PM (#19925378)
All of us are making assumptions about how much testing Tesla does internally before deploying a feature to customer cars. I think it's way more than the equivalent of "3 test patients", but from the outside of course there's no way to know.

From the linked tweet, there's no way to evaluate how unusual the failure case was. And of course we don't know how likely it was to have been a pedal misapplication. We do know that that's not uncommon, though.

The original comment I replied to assumed that there was no internal testing, and you're assuming there was very little internal testing. Both of you are jumping to that conclusion with very little support.

Re:Tesla crashes into wall during auto-park, Tesla: Beta fea... by NullPrefix on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @08:33AM (#19918740)
> Imagine a drug company put a drug on the market that might kill your or leave you crippled

Taking out of context by cutting off your sentence, but pretty much any drug has a listed side effect like this.

Re:Tesla crashes into wall during auto-park, Tesla: Beta fea... by bob_doggo on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @06:27AM (#19918008)
you are not wrong. But as I see it, the question here is about the legal status of having an open beta on items where a bug could kill someone.
Re:Tesla crashes into wall during auto-park, Tesla: Beta fea... by sesteel on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @09:00AM (#19918940)
Not as serious as death; but their argument suggests that the owners are subsidizing Tesla's R&D monetarily when their systems fail. I assume there is some type of legal agreement the owner had to click through to gain access to the feature. That is a pretty crappy situation for Tesla owners; hopefully, there is a way to opt out of agreements once opted in, given new information.
Re:Tesla crashes into wall during auto-park, Tesla: Beta fea... by heyyyouu on Wednesday May 15, 2019 @01:46PM (#19921883)
Yes, exactly.