News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The secret to fighting poverty is New Zealand by brc on Friday December 10, 2010 @04:41AM (#1991166)
A very misleading headline if you ask me. Of course taking someone out of a third world economy and putting them in a country with a stable government and employment possibilities is going to improve their lot.

It's not very scalable, though. You can't import a whole nation into another. And it only measures monetary benefits. Is there an increase in native New Zealanders unemployment? Is there an increase in rents? Is there an increase in family breakdown for the ones who are seasonally migrating?

Immigration issues are rarely one dimensional.

Re:The secret to fighting poverty is New Zealand by nl on Friday December 10, 2010 @05:41AM (#1991259)
Q: Is there an increase in native New Zealanders unemployment? A: these gains came with minimal displacement of native workers

The original article deals with some more of your objections.

Immigration issues are rarely one dimensional. True - in this case it does seem pretty beneficial.