Companies don't have a good track record of lasting more than 60 years. It's only a matter of time before they go bankrupt. And when bankruptcy is a way of shedding your pension obligations, they'll go out of their way to go bankrupt to shed it.
There are ways that companies can and do game the system. For example, during a merger the company might claim that the combined pension fund is overfunded and then stop making payments until the supposed net liability returns to 0. The "excess" funds often find their way into executives' pockets as bonuses, compensation for the several quarters where the company's ledger miraculously showed unexpected profits.
There are problems that need to be resolved, but they're resolvable. Private pensions can work, and have worked. Don't believe the rhetoric about pensions--it's largely driven by executives trying to raid pension funds. Executives don't like them because as compared to 401(k)s the ratio of executive compensation to worker compensation is lower. There are federal rules that require workers receive the same benefits as executives, and for various reasons executives will come out ahead with 401(k) packages.
The book Retirement Heist by then WSJ investigative journalist Ellen Schultz explains all the gory details.
Municipal pensions are irreparably broken, though, precisely because the federal rules regarding funding don't apply to them.
An index fund will underdiversify by only selecting public companies, and over-represent companies with short-term interests (the total opposite of a pension plan!).
The underdiversification or index funds is a particular issue ex-US where stock markets only represent a few sectors.
Pension plans can sure screw up, but they can also be unbeatable.
https://www.otpp.com/ https://hoopp.com/
They’re actually overfunded and have been (carefully) increasing benefits.
Then there is inflation. $5000/month for retirement sounds good now, but will it be when you actually get to retirement?
The techniques are just very different methods than how companies in many countries have defrauded their employees on pension liabilities.
My chief complaint about semi-forced annuity purchases is that those that opt-out and retire without savings get back-stopped by the state anyway.
Don't forget that you should have long term care insurance that covers a good nursing home (get this as soon as you retire when it is still cheap because odds are you will never need it).
With this plan you can outlive your savings and still have an okay life.
1) Canada Pension Plan, a worker-funded defined benefit pension managed by the government via an arms-length investment board.
2) Old Age Security, a guaranteed income program for everyone 65 and older.
3) Registered Retirement Savings Plan, an income tax sheltering program where you can contribute up to 18% of your income into registered accounts and have the contributions deducted from your taxable income. This gets drawn down during retirement for income.
Private companies have mostly stopped their pensions. Government employees usually have pensions, and they’re very well managed.