News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Crimes in Concrete by ppod on Monday May 13, 2019 @02:49PM (#19902531)
It's fascinating how neatly being politically conservative or progressive lines up with the corresponding architectural view. I like brutalism, but I disagree with the removal of Scruton from that position, it seems political. What annoys me about articles like the above is that they seem to ignore the possibility that aesthetics involves a lot of subjectivity. The argument seems to boil down to, "of course it's ugly, just look at it". But you look at what young travellers and photographers actually spend time appreciating and sharing images of, the modernist parts of Chicago, London and New York seem be appreciated at least as much as other cities and districts with well-regarded pre-20thC buildings.
Re:Crimes in Concrete by jdietrich on Monday May 13, 2019 @03:42PM (#19903150)
More to the point, look at what people choose to live in. Good modernist and brutalist homes sell quickly and at a significant premium over prevailing market rates.

Modernism got a bad name in many Western countries, because it was used as an architectural and philosophical justification for cheap and shoddy system-built housing to fill the post-war housing gap. That doesn't make rectilinear forms and bare concrete inherently bad; we don't blame vernacular architecture for characterless mock-Tudor estate houses and vulgar McMansions, we blame bad architects, profit-hungry developers and philistine houses.

https://www.themodernhouse.com/

https://vimeo.com/93963469

Re:Crimes in Concrete by icebraining on Monday May 13, 2019 @03:58PM (#19903293)
> Good modernist and brutalist homes sell quickly and at a significant premium over prevailing market rates.

I admit I wouldn't be asking if it agreed with my biases, but how do we know this? Seems hard to control for all the other variables.

Re:Crimes in Concrete by kd0amg on Monday May 13, 2019 @04:37PM (#19903688)
There are definitely some confounding factors other than architecture to account for. At least in Boston, new construction isn't replicating the century-old triple decker (of course, truly doing that would take a century of wear and tear). So I have to wonder how much of that price premium comes from having brand new stainless steel appliances and on-site gyms instead of creaky floors and questionable wiring. And then it seems to me, just wandering around town, the "modern" new construction is priced well above market price (lots of units sit vacant for a long time, with many eventually adding deal-sweetening offers like a month or two of free rent).
Re:Crimes in Concrete by rauhl on Monday May 13, 2019 @08:18PM (#19905484)
> Good modernist and brutalist homes sell quickly and at a significant premium over prevailing market rates.

Is that because they are good, or because they serve to signal class status?

Re:Crimes in Concrete by mywittyname on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @09:36AM (#19909293)
Modern homes are very expensive to build, so it isn't surprising that they fetch a premium on the market.
Re:Crimes in Concrete by NeedMoreTea on Monday May 13, 2019 @03:37PM (#19903098)
> It's fascinating how neatly being politically conservative or progressive lines up with the corresponding architectural view

Only it's really not that neat. When the brutalist monstrosities (you may correctly infer I don't like most of them one bit, though I do like much modernism) were being designed and built post-war, brutalism particularly was embraced as enthusiastically on all parts of the political spectrum. The mood was to build a "better world" and to borrow a cliche, embrace the "white heat of technology". Futurism, science, nuclear and modernism - including brutalism - was good. End of. Many fine examples of classic architecture were levelled, like the oft mourned Penn station, to put in an awesome, imposing brutalist slab that was looking tired and shabby within a decade. I'm sure the comparative cheapness and quickness of build won more fans in one part of the political map though.

As people started to live in them, use them, and live around them, it very rapidly became clear that brutalism - like much post-war architecture - didn't give a toss about humans. That was the real exciting new development in post-war architecture. The vision was inspiring, the reality was counter-productive in so many cases, as the scale or the amount of extra walking required wrecked the reality. They may have been impressive to look at, but so frequently fail to work as a building, or for people.

There are a few brutalist that work, and far more considered modernist, but in the main I call the brutalist experiment failed for those who have to use, inhabit or visit them. The ones that really work, seem to have one common feature - they remember the humans - you know, those things that use buildings? :)

Re:Crimes in Concrete by IfOnlyYouKnew on Monday May 13, 2019 @05:43PM (#19904293)
The was a somewhat more "humane" streak at the core of this movement than you make out. Specifically, these buildings were supposed to serve an egalitarian purpose, removing class differences previously expressed with fancy fascades etc.

This was also a time of far heavier air pollution than we today ever experience, at least in "the west". The typical multi-family building were therefore built not right at the sidewalk, but about 15m further back. Adjacent buildings no longer connected, but had similar spacing. The fraction of open space vs that used by buildings easily tripled, and the free space was planted with grass or brushes.

This was also the time when mixed zoning was mostly abolished in favour of homogenous residential or commercial areas.

As it turned out, this style isn't necessarily what people want. It tends to be too quiet, distances increase linear with lowered density, cars became somewhat required, etc. But the motives were mostly pure.

Re:Crimes in Concrete by NeedMoreTea on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @04:40AM (#19907785)
The motives were indeed good, but you seem to be missing a few things in places.

Bear in mind I'm in the UK, where Europe's post-war rebuilding was also large part of the motive. The American experience was necessarily a little different - no bomb damage, and a large profit from WW2, thank-you-very-much.

The huge areas of bomb damage, and decades of soot and other pollutants meant many of those fine classic buildings were looking old, tired and in need of sand-blasting, or at least a good wash. The 50s brought coal restrictions and clean air legislation, so pollution and smog had passed. Cars weren't yet common. Looking to the future concrete was "clean", and very much of the Jetson's future, and you got so much more of it for every pound spent. Steam trains, and Victorian gothic fussiness were of the mucky past. Yet unlike marble, granite and even sandstone and brick it so often weathers and ages horribly.

There was, as you note far more space - and in architect or promotional artistry before they were built this usually had trees, planting, and very often a view through trees. The other style was of people and cars as cells in the futuristic city organism - that Jetson future once again. The 95% reality had a few feature trees set in concrete or flagstones, some feature planters for flowers - horse trough or hot tub sized that in the sea of concrete looked comical afterthought. By the 70s the trees most especially were dying, horribly sad or missing. Turns out mature trees need more than 2 sq m of water capture. I remember very little grass in the brutalist bits of the city I grew up in or those I visited in the 70s and 80s. The sweeping walkways in the sky meant walking a mile to cross a road, or endless steps - horrible if mother with pram, and lastly plenty of dark gloomy spots to get mugged or lost in.

The pre-war modernist, or the garden city movements, and even pre-war social housing had, in the UK, far more of the natural world, grass, large grass verges with mature trees and play spaces or parks. They hadn't yet discovered separating shopping centre from housing, so they were still working communities.

So yeah, it's easy to see why they tried and the motives that brought them, but it's as easy to see why it so often turned out dystopian nightmare to be demolished as soon as affordable. We'll be stuck with those car-first choices for a century though. Today's alternative of finding lowest possible bid unless it's a feature tower block isn't that much better.

Re:Crimes in Concrete by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @09:52AM (#19909421)
The UK has a number of brutalist university campuses, but they're often set in extensive landscaping - which actually makes them quite pleasant.

But I wouldn't idolise pre-war architecture. There are some shockingly awful 1930s estates around London, and they're almost as dispiriting in their own way as archetypal brutalist tower blocks.

The garden cities are much more pleasant, but then you're not comparing like with like. Tower blocks were built to replace Victorian slums, with relatively high population density in both.

Some of the original designs were terrible, but sometimes they can be salvaged.

https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2019/may/12/grand-p...

Re:Crimes in Concrete by NeedMoreTea on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @12:07PM (#19910798)
I'm not idolising the 30s but that era does seem to have been something of a peak for public housing. Even with a few awful ones. It was the last major round of building before we got the post-war legislation that gave us overspill estates - almost guaranteed to be isolated sink estates and split families. At least part of the attitude that saw tower blocks cut off from the world by adding a major urban motorway or junction as part of the project.

You're completely right about the brutalist campuses, btw.

Re:Crimes in Concrete by zeveb on Monday May 13, 2019 @08:00PM (#19905345)
> The was a somewhat more "humane" streak at the core of this movement than you make out. Specifically, these buildings were supposed to serve an egalitarian purpose, removing class differences previously expressed with fancy fascades etc.

Maybe egalitarianism isn’t as humane as it seems. Maybe if you bring everyone down to the same level, you find that you’ve reduced everything worth striving for to rubble.

And maybe all those artisans and decorators the modernists drove out of business deserved to make a living too.

Re:Crimes in Concrete by jonhendry18 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @05:11PM (#19913942)
I assume Brutalism was also popular because it was cheap.
Re:Crimes in Concrete by deogeo on Monday May 13, 2019 @03:03PM (#19902708)
> modernist parts of Chicago, London and New York seem be appreciated at least as much as other cities and districts with well-regarded pre-20thC buildings.

Not according to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/America%27s_Favorite_Architect... - modernist buildings barely show up in that list. Of course you're right - beauty is subjective. So when a simple popularity poll fails to show support for their chosen style, architects resort to pseudo-intellectual justifications of why the people are wrong to dislike the featureless blocks of glass, steel and concrete built in their cities.

Re:Crimes in Concrete by jhbadger on Monday May 13, 2019 @03:31PM (#19903034)
Part of the problem is that modern buildings change their names as corporate clients change and hard to include in lists for that reason. For example, I grew up visiting Chicago and marveling at the wonderful Sears Tower and John Hancock Center. These days these are known as the Willis Tower and 875 North Michigan Avenue.
Re:Crimes in Concrete by LeanderK on Monday May 13, 2019 @04:42PM (#19903736)
> Not according to (..)

I am not sure, searching for "modern" reveals 27 hits and postmodern 14. Also, landmarks dominate the top 10 so i am not sure whether the poll more accuratly tracks the most liked building and not style. A style with more distributed votes would suffer (and, for example, there are more hits for postmodern than for art-deco).

Re:Crimes in Concrete by deogeo on Monday May 13, 2019 @05:48PM (#19904330)
Among the top 50, 5 are any sort of 'modern'. But is this ratio reflected in the types of buildings being built? Perhaps I would not be so bitter if only (27+14)/150 of new buildings were (post)modern in style. But, much like in art, it looks like the style can only exist if it suffocates all others.

Edit: By 'suffocate all others', I mean in an academic sense. Look at the designs produced by major architectural schools. They have been purged of older styles, just like the art world was purged of 'traditionally beautiful', confining it to art history.

Re:Crimes in Concrete by LeanderK on Monday May 13, 2019 @06:33PM (#19904689)
> Perhaps I would not be so bitter if only (27+14)/150 of new buildings were (post)modern in style. But, much like in art, it looks like the style can only exist if it suffocates all others.

This is a poll about americas favourite architecture and not in which style to build. I think the poll is largely a function of fame. Buildings are being build in all sorts of style, but I think the sobering result is that a style in itself is not really saving anyone. I also don't think style can only suffocate? A lot of cities are mixed in style.

Re:Crimes in Concrete by jonhendry18 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @05:14PM (#19913965)
I think such a list would be better for this argument if it were focused on a single city. ie, ranking buildings in just Chicago or New York.
Re:Crimes in Concrete by pjc50 on Monday May 13, 2019 @04:16PM (#19903480)
Scruton was a tobacco shill years ago: https://www.theguardian.com/media/2002/jan/24/advertising.to...

He's incapable of not being political. Publishing conspiracy theory garbage about Soros at the time of a major hunt for antisemitism in public life was what got him fired.

(The author of the original article, Dalrymple, is also a full time culture warrior)

Re:Crimes in Concrete by roca on Monday May 13, 2019 @11:27PM (#19906555)
I hope you've read both sides of that issue, e.g. https://www.spectator.co.uk/2019/04/the-scruton-tapes-an-ana...
Re:Crimes in Concrete by deogeo on Monday May 13, 2019 @05:39PM (#19904251)
Complaining about modern architectural style is being a culture warrior, but designing and building it is neutral and impartial...
Re:Crimes in Concrete by dsfyu404ed on Monday May 13, 2019 @07:07PM (#19904962)
Building at the high end (the kind of stuff HN cares about) is partly an exercise in artistic style which winds up being political.

Building at the low end is apolitical. With razor thin margins that crap doesnt make the cut. No matter how many millions of square feet of warehouse and pole barn you build there is no room for opinions, style and politics when your margin is pennies on the dollar.

Re:Crimes in Concrete by inflatableDodo on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @07:42AM (#19908595)
>Building at the high end (the kind of stuff HN cares about) is partly an exercise in artistic style which winds up being political.

>Building at the low end is apolitical.

You have an decidedly odd view of what people are interested in and what makes something political.

Re:Crimes in Concrete by jonhendry18 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @05:26PM (#19914049)
Low-income housing is extremely political.
Re:Crimes in Concrete by stupidcar on Monday May 13, 2019 @05:36PM (#19904224)
> The argument seems to boil down to, "of course it's ugly, just look at it"

Yes, but only because the heart of the modernist movement has been an attempt to deny, belittle and mock the idea that the instinctive aesthetic reaction of the majority to their creations is important or valid. If you think their constructions are ugly, that's not their problem, it's your problem. Firstly, you're too stupid, conservative and narrow-minded to perceive its genius, and secondly, in fact, you actually do like it, or eventually you will, if you just shut up and wait long enough.

It's as if avant-garde jazz advocates were put in charge every radio station and music streaming service on Earth, and given free rein to remorselessly enforce their taste on the whole population, with any dissenter being shouted down and told that, when they eventually forget what all other music sounded like, they'll come to love atonal jazz noise.

In such a situation, the fightback would have to begin with people being told it's OK to trust their own instinct and hate the music that's been forced upon them. Likewise, the fightback against overweening modernism has to begin by bursting the elitist bubble of faux-intellectual obfuscation that modernists have created around architecture. It has to begin by telling people that they have as much right to judge the aesthetics of huge changes to the places they live and work as anybody else, and that if they think the changes are ugly, then that's valid, without any "but..." unfolding into a lecture about how daring and original the latest edifice being foisted upon them actually is.

Re:Crimes in Concrete by Pils on Monday May 13, 2019 @08:03PM (#19905381)
So lets see:

- Modernism isn't a collection a movements across different countries/mediums in the early 20th century, but a "movement" whose "heart" is making intellectuals feel better than regular folks.

- No space for differing aesthetic opinions, the only real art is what you feel in your gut.

- Modernists are actively trying to change the places you live in work, despite the fact that the height of the movement happening decades ago.

- Specifically call out Jazz/Atonal music, apropos nothing.

Look, I'm all for differing opinions, but yours are more political than aesthetic (proving the parent's point). Plenty of modern architecture is aesthetically pleasing to the untrained eye. Some of it is not, and some of it is just objectively bad. However, your particular point of view, which presupposes some elite cabal, pushing there modernist agenda/degenerate art on an unknowing and unwilling populace, deserves some more scrutiny.

Re:Crimes in Concrete by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @10:14AM (#19909636)
In this context architecture is mostly about homes, so gut reactions aren't unreasonable.

And the Modernists very much were trying to change the landscape.

Here's a video about the Smithsons who designed one of the UK's largest housing projects. They're clearly serious and well-intentioned, but also... "eccentric" is probably a diplomatic description.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UH5thwHTYNk

But... it's worth remembering that these projects were replacements for slum housing, not showcase palaces and cathedrals. While they weren't ideal, they did usually manage to be warmer, healthier, cleaner, and more sanitary than the hovels they typically replaced.

Over time some of the harder egdes of modernism have been filed off, and modern projects seem to be trying to learn from the past, while still keeping the functionalism of the original modernists.

There are plenty of blocks on the European mainland which are very liveable, built in that style. And unless Mr Dalrymple wants to propose a new archiectural style that he thinks can improve on them, it's not worth taking him seriously - except as a self-indulgent grumbler.

Re:Crimes in Concrete by richardhod on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @03:45AM (#19907574)
Good points, yet for context there have been weird official conspiracies in modern art: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/modern-art-was-cia-...
Re:Crimes in Concrete by inflatableDodo on Monday May 13, 2019 @03:29PM (#19903018)
Having lived in and around some of London's brutalist experiments, is a bit like trying to get by in a glitched version of minecraft covered in sandpaper.
Re:Crimes in Concrete by michaelt on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @05:18AM (#19907952)

  But you look at what young travellers
  and photographers actually spend time
  appreciating and sharing images of
Abandoned, rusting power plants make great subjects for photography [1] - IMHO "striking photographs" is a poor proxy for beauty, popularity or good public architecture.

[1] https://abandonedsoutheast.com/2017/04/09/power-plant/

Re:Crimes in Concrete by jonhendry18 on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @05:10PM (#19913931)
Sturgeon's Law applies to Brutalist architecture as much as anything else. Most of it is terrible. The buildings that aren't terrible should be kept around. The buildings that are crap should be allowed to go away.

I think the animus towards Brutalism is far more prevalent and justified than animus towards modernism.

Re:Crimes in Concrete by on_and_off on Thursday May 16, 2019 @05:41PM (#19933626)
an article I stumbled upon today : https://www.timeout.fr/paris/sites-et-monuments/les-meilleur...

(in french but it you don't really need to read the text to appreciate the pictures)

Crimes in concrete really irked me in the way the author just assumes that they hold the truth about architectural beauty.

Re:Crimes in Concrete by Haga on Tuesday May 14, 2019 @03:34PM (#19913056)
What seems to be absolutely taboo is the synthesis of both views.. Very sad.
Re:Crimes in Concrete by coldtea on Monday May 13, 2019 @03:29PM (#19903014)
>What annoys me about articles like the above is that they seem to ignore the possibility that aesthetics involves a lot of subjectivity.

Well, in the case of such buildings, most of the subjective opinion is a resounding "nah".

>But you look at what young travellers and photographers actually spend time appreciating and sharing images of, the modernist parts of Chicago, London and New York seem be appreciated at least as much as other cities and districts with well-regarded pre-20thC building

What tourists take pictures of (and even for that, old buildings are unmatched in popularity) is hardly the criterion to judge buildings other unfortunate people have to live in, and with.

It's nice and edgy to photograph a brutalist monstrosity with some filters (oh, apocalyptic dystopian chic). It's another thing to live there.