Re:U.S. Farmers Are Being Bled by the Tractor Monopoly
by JMTQp8lwXL on Monday May 13, 2019 @01:04PM
(#19901292)
Surely some party would come in and fill the gap, reverse engineer the thing, whatever is necessary. Food security is a national security priority for the United States. We wouldn't go hungry if John Deere went under instantly. There would be a response.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:U.S. Farmers Are Being Bled by the Tractor Monopoly
by SilasX on Monday May 13, 2019 @01:45PM
(#19901745)
I'm not even sure it would reach the level of the federal government having to intervene. I imagine it would be more like:
1) Non-DRM'd tractors for this kind of thing would suddenly become valuable and used much more intensely (e.g. 24 hours a day).
2) Food prices would go up a bit as people shift to alternatives.
3) Everyone in the US cuts back on a few low-value uses of the grain (probably marginal livestock).
4) Some politicians bluster about the need for lower food prices, but there's no real will for significant change.
Then, after all the reverse engineering happens, things go back to normal.
Re:U.S. Farmers Are Being Bled by the Tractor Monopoly
by johnchristopher on Monday May 13, 2019 @01:24PM
(#19901489)
That's the "Is there an adult in the room" plan.
Re:U.S. Farmers Are Being Bled by the Tractor Monopoly
by CoffeeDregs on Monday May 13, 2019 @01:16PM
(#19901412)
That is certainly the hope. What is the plan?
Re:U.S. Farmers Are Being Bled by the Tractor Monopoly
by JMTQp8lwXL on Monday May 13, 2019 @01:26PM
(#19901517)
People are already hacking JD equipment with firmware found online. I don't have an exact answer to your question, but this thread seems over-blown. Somebody will know how it works, or learn how to work on it. I trust the ingenuity of this nation wouldn't leave us with an unmaintainable or unhackable tractors without "John Deere" the business existing, in the same way the technique for jailbreaking the latest version of iOS comes relatively quickly. The country that went to the moon can reverse engineer a tractor. It's not like we need to prove P = NP or not to start getting people fed again, to fix the problem.
Re:U.S. Farmers Are Being Bled by the Tractor Monopoly
by grawprog on Monday May 13, 2019 @01:42PM
(#19901702)
I personally agree the problem's being overblown here, and I agree with what you say about technology like that, but, just to counter a bit, when it comes to agriculture, time's not always available. Depending on when that theoretical stopping of Deere's servers were to occur. There could be massive crop failures. It's all well and good to get everything back up again, but by this time a loaf of bread costs $50 and everyone's flipping their shit.
Not that I think any of this is ever likely to happen, but even small disruptions to the food supply can have large consequences.
Re:U.S. Farmers Are Being Bled by the Tractor Monopoly
by throwtt78oo65 on Monday May 13, 2019 @03:06PM
(#19902744)
I would be surprised if there weren’t several Chinese companies trying.
It would be really funny if one was Huawei.