Re:F() vs. F(void) in C vs. C++
by kazinator on Monday May 13, 2019 @10:42AM
(#19899715)
Compilers that allow type punning through a union have to basically consider the access to a member of the union to have an effect on any other member. It's conceivable that there are edge cases where that consideration could hamper the optimization of a code which uses unions without perpetrating any sort of type punning. Hmm, like what?
Say we have a really contrived function that works with two pointers A and B to the same union type. The compiler cannot prove that A and B are distinct. The function evaluates A->x = expr, and also B->y in several places. Since A and B might be the same pointer, the assignment has to be regarded as clobbering B->y, which interferes with CSE of B->y and register caching.
As of C99, a possible solution here would be to declare the pointers restrict; then the compiler assumes they don't overlap: A->x has nothing to do with B->y.
If a struct is used, then x and y are different members and have nothing to do with each other for that reason, needless to say, even if A and B are the same pointer.
Re:F() vs. F(void) in C vs. C++
by TeMPOraL on Monday May 13, 2019 @12:15PM
(#19900766)
Given that this is C, can the compiler prove in any case that two pointers are distinct? When you're dealing with a structure, it could still be the case that A = B + sizeof(structure.x) (+/- padding).
Say we have a really contrived function that works with two pointers A and B to the same union type. The compiler cannot prove that A and B are distinct. The function evaluates A->x = expr, and also B->y in several places. Since A and B might be the same pointer, the assignment has to be regarded as clobbering B->y, which interferes with CSE of B->y and register caching.
As of C99, a possible solution here would be to declare the pointers restrict; then the compiler assumes they don't overlap: A->x has nothing to do with B->y.
If a struct is used, then x and y are different members and have nothing to do with each other for that reason, needless to say, even if A and B are the same pointer.