News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Most Scientists in the U.S. Are Democrats. That's a Problem by joe_the_user on Thursday December 09, 2010 @06:01PM (#1989634)
Oddly enough, I think most scientist are opposed to immoral experiments as well.

The question is whether or not one is using rational criteria to determine what's moral.

Re:Most Scientists in the U.S. Are Democrats. That's a Problem by yummyfajitas on Thursday December 09, 2010 @06:13PM (#1989682)
Most opponents of stem cell research are being rational. If you take as an axiom "fertilized eggs are people too", it's not hard to conclude that stem cell experiments are immoral.

In much the same way, given the axiom "blacks are people too", the rational conclusion is that Tuskegee was immoral.

Re:Most Scientists in the U.S. Are Democrats. That's a Problem by subsection1h on Thursday December 09, 2010 @09:52PM (#1990382)
Most opponents of stem cell research are being rational. If you take as an axiom "fertilized eggs are people too", it's not hard to conclude that stem cell experiments are immoral.

Fertilized eggs can divide. Is it rational to believe that a person can divide? Is each twin 50% of a person?

Re:Most Scientists in the U.S. Are Democrats. That's a Problem by yummyfajitas on Thursday December 09, 2010 @10:30PM (#1990472)
If your definition of people includes fertilized eggs, then it is clearly rational to believe a person can divide.
Re:Most Scientists in the U.S. Are Democrats. That's a Problem by joe_the_user on Thursday December 09, 2010 @09:31PM (#1990313)
If that is the premise of opponents of stem cell research, they may be drawing rational, moral conclusions from it.

However the premise itself, "stem cells are people" is most certainly definitely drawn from religious faith.

The premise that black people are rather similar to white people, on the other hand, seems to draw on scientific knowledge. Obviously, there's still the step of drawing a rational, moral conclusion from that also.

Re:Most Scientists in the U.S. Are Democrats. That's a Problem by yummyfajitas on Thursday December 09, 2010 @10:27PM (#1990462)
Scientific statement: "Black people are biologically similar (for some definition of similar) to white people."

Moral statement: "Creatures with X degree of similarity to white people deserve the same rights as white people."

The latter statement is simply unprovable via the scientific method. Forget even about the racism - the statement "you shouldn't rape/torture/murder people" also can't be proved via the scientific method.