Re:Why falsificationism is false
by mannykannot on Monday May 13, 2019 @07:51AM
(#19898305)
Insofar as your objections are meaningful (in particular, I am not so sure about the last), it would seem they could equally be raised about non-simulation physical theories of the universe. Would that make those meaningless?
I would think that, on the contrary, the fact that you can raise these objections indicates that the simulation hypothesis is not without meaning, as does Scott Aaronson's argument that it is unfalsifiable[1] (note: he is not saying that that it is meaningless), and as does Bostrom's argument that if it is possible, we are likely in a simulation[2].
When you think of a simulation, you might imagine a programmer, some server racks, and maybe a broader purpose. However you also have to include the possibility that the simulation popped into existence out of nothing, that the simulation is mathematically inevitable, that God created the simulation, that the simulation was created by beings that live in simulation... In so many words, the idea that you live in a simulation leaves as many options open as the idea that you live in the universe. You don't get any claims about how the simulation got there, how it behaves, or even what it is
Maybe it is a meaningless idea.