“a breath mint for your balls.”[0]
[0] https://gizmodo.com/lessons-learned-from-a-year-living-in-a-...
Sounds like that might have been the baby unscented variety instead of the peppermint. Both have blue labels but the peppermint one is a darker shade.
I once met someone who wrote a song about the tingly effect (probably not the only one...).
Since I am commenting late I'll mention here that I suspect the main reason for the current popularity in the US is that it became a universal feature of health food stores and co-ops before they were all that popular. When Whole Foods took health food stores mainstream they sold it and when supermarkets responded with natural products departments they started selling it too. So now it is not only a good quality soap with a relatively short ingredient list but very widely available.
Dr Bronner’s Peppermint soap was in the shower. Not knowing any better, I did a good lather. When I started feeling a tingle in my critical region, I didn’t know what to do. Thankfully, rinsing off kept me from becoming uncomfortable.
This lead to some cautious conversations with the coworkers, and as we confirmed a similar experiences this contributed to a very different experience to bond over.
There is additional backstory, where the Peppermint was bought be accident to replace a previous blue bottle that had generously been left there. The purchaser of the replacement had been equally surprised by the effects.
Since then I’ve gotten to enjoy rotating to the peppermint or tea tree oil soap from time to time.