News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Academe’s Extinction Event: Failure, Whiskey, and Profess... by Eliezer on Sunday May 12, 2019 @12:27PM (#19892841)
The books I've read on the professional craft of writing (written by successful authors) have emphasized that you can't expect to learn anything from your English professor - and many of those books were from decades before the collapse described here. This area of academe is widely considered a fraud, not just by evil Republican governors, but by the only people with externally visible expertise in its supposed subject matter. I don't know if it's collapsing because of the fraud, if there's causality; but my understanding is that the conventional belief among people who can actually write is that the MLA can't read.
Re:Academe’s Extinction Event: Failure, Whiskey, and Profess... by jseliger on Sunday May 12, 2019 @02:05PM (#19893441)
This area of academe is widely considered a fraud

I think the intellectual problems and economic problems are linked: https://jakeseliger.com/2014/10/02/what-happened-with-decons...

Re:Academe’s Extinction Event: Failure, Whiskey, and Profess... by bilbo0s on Sunday May 12, 2019 @12:48PM (#19892946)
You're talking about something slightly different than the article. What you're talking about might more precisely be directed at something like a creative writing program. What the article's author is discussing is, in layman's terms, the profession of being an analyst-, or the profession of giving "critique"-, of creative writers.
Re:Academe’s Extinction Event: Failure, Whiskey, and Profess... by Eliezer on Sunday May 12, 2019 @02:06PM (#19893443)
It's a bad sign if all the creative writers with external viability think the MLA obviously has no expertise on the underlying structure of books. I can imagine an art of critiquing proofs, but I'd expect it to be headed up by professional mathematicians or at least be in good standing with them.
Re:Academe’s Extinction Event: Failure, Whiskey, and Profess... by mcguire on Sunday May 12, 2019 @01:05PM (#19893058)
No, I think it's exactly right. The "destruction" the author describes is the cause of the inwardness and nearsightedness that makes much of it useless.
Re:Academe’s Extinction Event: Failure, Whiskey, and Profess... by Fomite on Sunday May 12, 2019 @09:52PM (#19895890)
This is exactly like saying you don't learn how to code well from your CS professor.

They're different skills that are in a related arena.