News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why falsificationism is false by klyrs on Saturday May 11, 2019 @04:36PM (#19888247)
> Is your statement that 'only falsifiable claims are meaningful' itself falsifiable? If so, what sort of experiment would you set up to test it?

As a mathematician, I've always looked on this issue with some bemusement. Physicists are particularly egregious in their abuse of mathematical notation, yet get very fussy about what constitutes "proof." If we consider a result measured to "five nines" of uncertainty -- scratch that -- if we consider a million results measured to "five nines" of uncertainty, than we're almost certain to have "proved" a falsehood. And that's assuming that everybody is using complete models with no missing variables (protip: they're not). And then they turn around and heap scorn on "soft sciences" which deign to apply scientific methodology to systems too small, and far too complicated for such simplistic modeling, where experimentalists jump through extraordinary hoops to avoid ethical disasters.

The need for falsifiability is a strongly-held opinion. And don't get me wrong, it's a great rule of thumb. From a mathematical basis, I can take a stab at your question. If you have a million data points, you can find a million-degree polynomial to fit it. If you're allowed to adjust the polynomial every time we make a new observation, it's unfalsifiable. However, that approach is rightly seen as problematic because the predictive power (that is, meaningfulness) is zero. But of course, this is only an existence proof (aka, an anecdote), that some unfalsifiable theories are meaningless. It doesn't prove that all unfalsifiable theories are meaningless.

There are no comments on this comment yet.