News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why falsificationism is false by whatshisface on Saturday May 11, 2019 @04:19PM (#19888155)
>would you have considered Democritus's atomic theory to be meaningless, given the lack of any conceivable path to test it at the time?

Strictly speaking Democritus's atomic theory is still untestable today because it doesn't include the actual scale of the atoms. For all we know the apparently continuous quantum fields are themselves made of "atoms" (in his sense, not the modern meaning of the word atom). If he had said "things will get clearly atom-y around a nanometer" then it would have been at least conceivable that someone could eventually look that closely.

>you have to take quite an expansive view of what is 'conceivable'

That's right, I was laying down a very liberal criteria (and saying that it was a necessary but insufficient condition).

>If so, what sort of experiment would you set up to test it?

That's kind of like asking what sort of experiment could disprove the law of the excluded middle: not an unreasonable question, but the answer is going to sound pretty silly. To test my claim, you could iterate though every claim about the universe, checking to see if it simultaneously could not contradict with any observation, and yet predicted what you would observe. Good luck actually doing it; but it does technically meet my criterion.

Re:Why falsificationism is false by smallnamespace on Saturday May 11, 2019 @09:32PM (#19889531)
> That's right, I was laying down a very liberal criteria

> but the answer is going to sound pretty silly.

Yes, I was trying to illustrate that the line between 'science' and 'metaphysics' is necessarily a blurry one, and the choice of (and justification for) where to draw it itself lies in the realm of metaphysics.

The broader the universe of claims you admit as scientific, the more 'testability' and 'falsifiability' lie closer to the realm of theory. However, even theories (and paradigms) that can't be directly placed on the experimenter's bench today can point towards fruitful lines of investigation.

On the flip side, we can't but to make metaphysical (and therefore non-scientific) claims and hold them as true, despite our best efforts ... the strong version of 'scientism' (that only scientific claims can have meaning) is a self-defeating one.