Re:Why falsificationism is false
by whatshisface on Saturday May 11, 2019 @04:28PM
(#19888206)
That's just the common mistake of incorrectly encoding one's beliefs in logic and then complaining logic doesn't work. If you think there might be a glass pane between you and a colored ball, your true belief is (No glass pane implies green ball), not (green ball).
If you don't mind me getting on my soap box, it kind of seems like the recipe for coming up with a renowned counterargument to a technical tool goes like:
- Find a technical device that you don't understand.
- Misuse it because you don't understand it.
- Notice that it isn't working.
- Conclude that logic doesn't work, math doesn't work, science doesn't work, the bug is in the compiler, take your pick.
It's not clear what you mean or are complaining about. Feel free to provide your own example. Just come up with two empirical claims (A and B) such that you think A contradicts B. It should then be relatively easy to come up with a C that, if C were true, A would no longer contradict B. It's obvious once you start laying things out carefully.
Re:Why falsificationism is false
by whatshisface on Saturday May 11, 2019 @04:40PM
(#19888271)
Here's a specific example. Claim A: "If nothing is wrong with your experiment or analysis, you will observe that the speed of light in a vacuum is the same in all inertial reference frames up to experimental uncertainty." Claim B: "If nothing is wrong with your experiment or analysis, you will observe that the speed of light in a vacuum is different in every inertial reference frame up to experimental uncertainty."
Every experimentalist realizes that their real result is "I didn't make a mistake -> the answer is X," not "the answer is X." That's the correct way to encode an experiment in logic, leaving aside the high sophistication of how "I didn't make a mistake" gets treated in practice.
Re:Why falsificationism is false
by marcosdumay on Saturday May 11, 2019 @06:06PM
(#19888671)
There's always something between you and the ball. The era of completely defined and easily observable experiments is long gone. Today we are always composing inherited theories.
If you want an example, consider an ordinary empirical observation. Someone claims the ball is red; you look and you see green. Classic contradiction, right? Except if lighting conditions are wrong, or there is a pane of colored glass between you, or.. The point is that there are additional claims that, if they were true, would remove the "contradicts" relation between the two original claims. But ordinary logical relationships shouldn't work like that.