News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GraalVM 19.0 by jarym on Saturday May 11, 2019 @12:07PM (#19886819)
I’d say it is nefarious to put out an EE version that’s marked ‘production use requires a license’ and then make it impossible to figure out how to get a license or what one would cost.

Even enterprises would deep budgets would not let their devs near such an arrangement - they could be held to ransom by Oracle!

If it’s not ready or ‘fully baked’ as you say then mark it as beta and say that future versions will require a license.

Re:GraalVM 19.0 by StevePerkins on Saturday May 11, 2019 @12:20PM (#19886887)
Well, yes. Devs in that environment would not go near it (at least not for anything beyond a POC). In those environments, you have to go through a review board process in order to use some new open source JSON-parser library from Maven Central. Devs aren't just cowboy'ing a new compiler into their workflow.

"Production use requires a license" is a NOT an indicator that it's ready for production use (there are a number of warnings against this). The fact that you need a license, yet can't get one, is a clear signal that it isn't ready for production use. The people in Oracle's target audience see this sort of thing a lot with preview software, and aren't confused by it.

Re:GraalVM 19.0 by jarym on Saturday May 11, 2019 @01:18PM (#19887243)
> The fact that you need a license, yet can't get one, is a clear signal that it isn't ready for production use.

Everything you said is reasonable except this. If it isn’t ready for production use then no need to beat about the bush by advertising a commercial license you can’t get? And if one doesn’t exist by the way how are Twitter using it in production?

Re:GraalVM 19.0 by StevePerkins on Saturday May 11, 2019 @01:29PM (#19887299)
I honestly don't know how to explain this more clearly. They are not "advertising a commercial license". They are saying NOT to use the Enterprise version in production, because licensing is not yet available.

The only reference I've ever seen to Twitter using GraalVM in production is in this discussion thread. And that commenter clearly states that Twitter is using the open-source community edition.

No one who would ever conceivably be a paying Oracle customer would be confused by any of this. When that much money is on the table, there are experienced people in the room with reading comprehension.

Re:GraalVM 19.0 by tom_mellior on Saturday May 11, 2019 @04:53PM (#19888334)
> They are not "advertising a commercial license".

https://blogs.oracle.com/graalvm/announcement "GraalVM Enterprise is available for purchase and is free on Oracle Cloud."

> They are saying NOT to use the Enterprise version in production

[citation needed]

> The only reference I've ever seen to Twitter using GraalVM in production is in this discussion thread.

Considering that Twitter has been talking about this in public for some time, this statement is unlikely to make the point you were trying to make: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pR5NDkIZBOA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PtgKmzgIh4c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZbccuoaLChk

Re:GraalVM 19.0 by kjeetgill on Saturday May 11, 2019 @02:05PM (#19887459)
Twitter uses the free GPL Community Edition in production. EE is faster but a lot of the magick is in the open source one.