But I see your other points and they're all good. I don't know if the law of unintended consequences would mean union competition became a race to the bottom or a race to the top. But I think some unions are not as effective as others, and I don't know why that is.
Some unions elect people to lead them who are corrupt, and want to simply hoard the power for themselves and those closest to them.
Some unions elect people to lead them who are incompetent, and no matter how hard they try, they can't achieve the union's goals.
And some unions elect people to lead them who have both the desire and the ability to genuinely achieve the union's goals, and make things better for the workers without crippling the business(es) they work for.
Looking at long-standing unions, the problem is multiplied further by entrenched attitudes, cultures, and even rules that differentiate them, built up over more than a century. Some of these will likely increase effectiveness, while others will hamper it.
All of this is, incidentally, a big part of why most anti-union rhetoric is so frustrating to me: it paints all unions as being one thing (and a bad thing at that), when it's painfully obvious that there is no fundamental requirement for unions to, for instance, make sure that terrible employees are un-fireable. It's just something that's built up in some of the old, crusty ones.
In a great touch of irony, this means that the most exploited workers are frequently those who have the most trouble parting with income to support forming a Union.
However, it just so happens that by instituting one, the Union can become itself more equal in what it can run down and discover about the company itself, creating a more equal entity sitting across from the corporate lawyers on the other side of the table.
What everyone wants is for company and employee alike to just play fair. When only one of you has the financials on your side however...
Well that quickly goes out the window.
All in all, I think Unions should make a bigger comeback during times when the labor force is getting shafted.
Is that time now? I'm not sure. Haven't checked their financials.