Re:Google Is Bringing Electronic IDs to Android
by MiddleEndian on Friday May 10, 2019 @10:52PM
(#19884230)
I'm sure there are some, perhaps I was too colloquial when I said nobody, but there is no widespread movement to give non-citizens the ability to vote in US elections. My main point is that opposition to voter ID wouldn't have much to do with that because that's not how voter registration works in the US. The post I had responded to was a mischaracterization of the reasons people are opposed to voter IDs.
On the topic of residents voting, a city near me had a policy+budget allocation vote that allowed anyone who lived there and was over 13. My opinion on that is that I think that's pretty neat at a city level, but I don't think it makes sense to allow non citizens to vote in a federal election.
It doesn't seem to be catastrophic for New Zealand, for instance.
There's a strong argument to be made that people participating in the economy and other parts of civic life deserve to have a voice in politics. It's convenient and popular to exclude them, that doesn't make it just.
(I phrase my first paragraph the way I do because I haven't thought about it much and don't have a real clear opinion 'bout it)