Re:‘Build More Housing’ Is No Match for Inequality
by dragonwriter on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:41PM
(#19873611)
> If you build more housing and prices don’t go down, that means your satisfying unmet demand.
That's not in dispute.
> And that’s a good thing too
It's a good thing if the tax revenue plus positive externalities created by the additional residents outweighs the public service cost and negative externalities.
It is by no means given that this is the case.
> If you keep building, then at some point the unmet demand will be met
Assuming that the unmet demand doesn't expand faster than you build, sure. And since if you build fast enough you adversely impact living conditions and decrease demand, that's actually quite easy to guarantee. OTOH, no one in the existing population wants that, and no in government wants that on their resume.
Can you realistically meet unmet demand in a small city with high global demand other than by crushing demand by making the city unattractive to live in? It is not obvious that the answer is yes, and it's not really an attractive experiment to run.
That's not in dispute.
> And that’s a good thing too
It's a good thing if the tax revenue plus positive externalities created by the additional residents outweighs the public service cost and negative externalities.
It is by no means given that this is the case.
> If you keep building, then at some point the unmet demand will be met
Assuming that the unmet demand doesn't expand faster than you build, sure. And since if you build fast enough you adversely impact living conditions and decrease demand, that's actually quite easy to guarantee. OTOH, no one in the existing population wants that, and no in government wants that on their resume.
Can you realistically meet unmet demand in a small city with high global demand other than by crushing demand by making the city unattractive to live in? It is not obvious that the answer is yes, and it's not really an attractive experiment to run.