News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber prices blockbuster IPO conservatively to raise $8.1B by shereadsthenews on Thursday May 09, 2019 @06:24PM (#19873034)
Congratulations you have just committed the elementary Chinese Soda fallacy.
Re:Uber prices blockbuster IPO conservatively to raise $8.1B by parhamn on Thursday May 09, 2019 @06:28PM (#19873065)
While I knew what you were implying, I wanted to see if this was actually a common term. It isn't but it did lead me to another HN comment [1] and this Fast Company article referring to is as "Chinese Math" [2]. Just an FYI for anyone else because this sort of "1% of x market" thing comes a lot and a term is helpful to speed up the convos.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10735610

[2] https://www.fastcompany.com/1710460/chinese-math-or-1-mistak...

Re:Uber prices blockbuster IPO conservatively to raise $8.1B by SilasX on Thursday May 09, 2019 @06:40PM (#19873166)
I didn't know the term for it [1], but yes, I had long since started checking out whenever someone starts to appeal to "if we can just get n% of <huge market>".

[1] Even "Chinese Soda" has not entered common usage enough to justify calling it "the" or "a standard" term for it.

Re:Uber prices blockbuster IPO conservatively to raise $8.1B by panarky on Thursday May 09, 2019 @09:28PM (#19874264)
The "Chinese math" fallacy is only fallacious when it hides how difficult it is to steal a small percentage of a giant established market.

How exactly does the "fallacy" apply to Uber, a company that thoroughly understands how difficult it is to carve a big chunk out of entrenched competitors?

Since they've already demonstrated the ability to steal a sizable percentage of the taxi and car rental markets, it's good for Uber that they didn't listen to all the smart guys on HN.

Re:Uber prices blockbuster IPO conservatively to raise $8.1B by SilasX on Friday May 10, 2019 @11:00AM (#19878406)
>The "Chinese math" fallacy is only fallacious when it hides how difficult it is to steal a small percentage of a giant established market.

Which is what I was using it for.

>How exactly does the "fallacy" apply to Uber, a company that thoroughly understands how difficult it is to carve a big chunk out of entrenched competitors?

To clarify, that part is not the problem with the comment. That is a legit argument for why Uber can justify its valuation.

The problem is trying to amplify the persuasiveness of the argument by appealing to "small percent of huge = big". That deceptively makes the argument more appealing than it deserves to be, and is a lazy form of justifying a valuation. It plays tricks with human intuition on big numbers to (as you note) underplay the difficulty of getting a small number.

Hence why it's a "reach for my revolver" type situation.

Be careful not to equate "they have, independently of this argument, a good case here" with "therefore it's not the Chinese Soda fallacy to mention the percentages."

Re:Uber prices blockbuster IPO conservatively to raise $8.1B by ghaff on Thursday May 09, 2019 @06:39PM (#19873148)
I consulted for someone once to do some market sizing among other things. They were determined to make a case around winning 10% or whatever for the worldwide market for X.
Re:Uber prices blockbuster IPO conservatively to raise $8.1B by cfitz on Thursday May 09, 2019 @06:31PM (#19873084)
It would be helpful to others if you explained what exactly your purported fallacy entails.

I can find only one other reference to it and it's on HN.

Re:Uber prices blockbuster IPO conservatively to raise $8.1B by shereadsthenews on Thursday May 09, 2019 @06:44PM (#19873192)
The way it was taught to me, decades ago because I’m old and people used to say “Chinaman” out loud, was the fallacious line of thinking begins “if I can just sell every Chinaman one Coke...”. The Fast Company article is right on.
Re:Uber prices blockbuster IPO conservatively to raise $8.1B by bduerst on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:19PM (#19873477)
So the 1% fallacy - i.e. "if we could just get 1% of this huge market we will be billionaires!" (ignoring the costs involved).

Basically every other episode of Shark Tank.

Re:Uber prices blockbuster IPO conservatively to raise $8.1B by cfitz on Thursday May 09, 2019 @07:19PM (#19873469)
Thank you, I appreciate the added historical context. Will give the Fast Company article linked above a read.
Re:Uber prices blockbuster IPO conservatively to raise $8.1B by ghaff on Thursday May 09, 2019 @06:41PM (#19873168)
It’s not that uncommon. I’ve certainly heard of it. But basically winning 1% of sizable markets is neither easy or cheap in most cases.