News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Transparent Solar Panels Will Turn Windows into Green Ene... by vkou on Thursday May 09, 2019 @03:52PM (#19871682)
1. Utility solar will always be cheaper then distributed solar.

2. The biggest limiting factor on renewable adoption is cost.

3. We will never run out of space to put solar panels.

The last thing I need is a pile of extensive, over-complicated, version 1.0 technology and all of its electrical wiring, etc crammed into my windows.

Re:Transparent Solar Panels Will Turn Windows into Green Ene... by gumby on Thursday May 09, 2019 @04:01PM (#19871795)
> Utility solar will always be cheaper then distributed solar.

And mainframes will always be cheaper than distributed computing.

I believe the economics favor the utility approach now and for the immediate future but would be reluctant to put my money on always/never

Re:Transparent Solar Panels Will Turn Windows into Green Ene... by vkou on Thursday May 09, 2019 @04:58PM (#19872352)
1. Mainframes are cheaper then distributed computing. We call them 'the cloud' these days.

If pointless things like solar windows become cheaper then utility solar, then utilities will just build farms of solar windows. You know what's easier then installing a solar window in a house wall? Installing one at ground level, without worrying about walls.

Instead of having a handyman drive for 50 minutes, and then spend two hours tearing apart my house to install 6 windows in it, they could have him install an array of 90 of them in one day at a utility site. Hell, he won't even need to make sure that they don't leak.

Re:Transparent Solar Panels Will Turn Windows into Green Ene... by gumby on Thursday May 09, 2019 @05:17PM (#19872523)
This was the argument against PCs too. And in the late 70s I was already using cloud computing (MIT lispms and PARC systems like grapevine) that were not using mainframes. The economics seemed clear, but a variety of path dependence and economy of scale issues meant the mainframe survived quite a while (and is still going strong, but isn't dominant). But we are doing more edge computing than ever before with supercomputers in every pocket, game consoles and the like.

I have also worked in distributed solar. That's why I understand that the existing utility model still has a long way to run. Where I disagree is that there might be an inherent advantage.

Re:Transparent Solar Panels Will Turn Windows into Green Ene... by aqme28 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @04:17PM (#19871961)
> The biggest limiting factor on renewable adoption is cost.

Often the biggest cost for a solar project is the installation. If they somehow make these windows roughly as easy to install as a regular window, this could actually be a very economical approach.

Re:Transparent Solar Panels Will Turn Windows into Green Ene... by newnewpdro on Thursday May 09, 2019 @04:07PM (#19871855)
> 1. Utility solar will always be cheaper then distributed solar.

Utilities are often privatized monopolies these days, that's not at all a safe assumption. Look what happened with California and Enron.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enron#California's_deregulatio...

Re:Transparent Solar Panels Will Turn Windows into Green Ene... by vkou on Thursday May 09, 2019 @08:25PM (#19873906)
And look at what happened to SolarCity, and similar firms. That space is unable to operate profitably, despite large federal subsidies. It also has no shortage of scammy ownership/loans-for-your-solar-install model, is a bad investment for most homeowners, and doesn't even answer the hundred-thousand-dollar-per-home question of peak energy storage. (Or how it can operate in a world where you are on an even playing field for selling power to the grid as the utility.)

The home solar industry makes most power utilities look both efficient and competent.

Re:Transparent Solar Panels Will Turn Windows into Green Ene... by amluto on Thursday May 09, 2019 @04:11PM (#19871908)
Also, look at the hilariously high cost of electricity in PG&E territory. If you can deal with storage and peak loads, on-site generation is competing with 20-40 cents / kWh charged by PG&E, not the vastly lower prices that PG&E pays for generation.
Re:Transparent Solar Panels Will Turn Windows into Green Ene... by newnewpdro on Thursday May 09, 2019 @04:22PM (#19872028)
Downed PG&E transmission lines are also implicated in causing fires in the state, just another argument in favor of decentralized, on-site generation.