News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Making Nuclear Energy Smaller, Cheaper And Safer by Animats on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @02:09PM (#19861425)
"My concern about NuScale is that they believe so deeply that their reactor is safe and doesn't need to meet the same criteria as the larger reactors, that it's pushing for lots of exemptions and exceptions," says Edwin Lyman, acting director of the Nuclear Safety Project at the Union of Concerned Scientists.

Here's a picture of the setup.[1] The reactors all share the same pool. The pool is big enough to absorb the heat in an emergency, and passive heat transfer from reactor to pool is high due to a smaller reactor size, and all this passively prevents a meltdown.

So they have one class of failure covered. But that's not the only possible failure. Leaks into the pool become a big problem, because one reactor can contaminate the pool and all the other reactors. Three Mile Island had a valve failure and contaminated the containment vessel. That was expensive to clean up, and made the reactor useless, but didn't cause trouble outside the plant. A plumbing leak with NuScale could take down all the reactors.

[1] https://www.world-nuclear-news.org/Articles/NuScale-SMR-ente...

Re:Making Nuclear Energy Smaller, Cheaper And Safer by mcguire on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @04:15PM (#19862448)
"The pool is big enough to absorb the heat in an emergency, and passive heat transfer from reactor to pool is high due to a smaller reactor size, and all this passively prevents a meltdown."

Out of curiosity, how is heated water circulated through the pool? I have this sudden vision of the reactor boiling the water around it and being surrounded by a pocket of steam. Or, the repeated formation and collapse of a steam bubble, which can't be good.