News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by frereubu on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @12:34PM (#19860503)
This ties in quite nicely with Karl Friston's Free Energy Principle: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NIu_dJGyIQI

There are so many strands of neuroscience that show predictive coding now. There's a really nice example in the use of common vs unusual words in sentences. If you're using fMRI to scan someone while they read these two sentences:

The jam on the motorway made everything slow.

The jam on the motorway made everything sticky.

You'll see a flash of activity when people read the word "sticky" rather than the more common word in that context "slow". The theory is that when everything in the sentence proceeds as predicted there's very little need to update prior expectations, but when you come across something that goes against previous predictions it's a signal that something needs to be actively thought about.

Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by ta1234567890 on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @02:31PM (#19861601)
Cool! This sounds similar to koans: "a paradoxical anecdote or riddle, used in Zen Buddhism to demonstrate the inadequacy of logical reasoning and to provoke enlightenment."

If you explore the meaning of language enough you'll realize it doesn't really make sense.

Everything is based on context and assumptions that we take for granted when communicating. But if you dig deep enough (and it's really not that deep anyway), you'll notice that pretty much anything you say or write can be interpreted in multiple different ways, which means there's no one absolute meaning to any expression of language.

Meaning comes from interpretation, which is subjective and unique to the person doing it.

Interesting exercise: for a day or a week, make an effort to think how anything that someone else says to you is actually true - asume they are always right and think about how to justify it. It's really amazing, at first it's really hard, but then you discover you can always just interpret what they say in a way that fits your views.

Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by soulofmischief on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @07:05PM (#19863791)
I think you can make unambiguous sentences: "I walked one mile today." Unless context specifically indicates the very rare possibility that walked is personal shorthand for another activity, it's a pretty unambiguous statement.
Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by p1necone on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @07:32PM (#19863973)
I can think of two different ways to interpret that sentence.

1: They went for a walk as a single activity on top of their regular daily walking, and that walk was a mile long.

2. They walked a total of 1 mile throughout the entire day, including regular walking around the house/office etc.

I do agree with the sentiment though, there definitely are plenty of unambiguous sentences you can say in everyday conversation.

Perhaps "my refrigerator is currently powered on" is an arbitrary example that works.

Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by soulofmischief on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @07:35PM (#19863988)
That's pretty good. But then knowing that ambiguity, I could craft a statement like, "I walked a mile on the treadmill today."
Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by ta1234567890 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @12:10AM (#19865308)
Exactly, and if you keep going, you'd notice you need each time a longer, more precise description, which at the same time, paradoxically, opens the door for more ambiguity.

In that example, the first context is English language, then knowing who I is, then what a mile is, and a treadmill and today. All of those are contextual. Even mile. How long is a mile? Like any physical measure, it actually varies, because it is defined relative to something else which varies. The meaning of English language has also varied over time, that sentence might not make any sense to someone reading it in 20 years. And then when is today? May 7, 2019 - which is also a relative measure of time and not even that precise.

And then finally, what if you were lying? Did you really walk a mile today? How can I be sure? And how can you be sure I understand the same meaning from the words you say or write?

Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by soulofmischief on Thursday May 09, 2019 @12:32AM (#19865417)
I understand where you are coming from, but a lot of what you just presented isn't actually relevant to the topic of ambiguity from lack of context in language. Some of it just doesn't apply. Allow me to explain...

> the first context is English language

Let's ignore this context. If you don't understand English then you shouldn't be expected to understand an English statement regardless of context.

> How long is a mile?

That depends on what time and space you are in. But that's ok. All such measurements are relative and defined by non-natural constructs. But we can be realistic and assume a mile is whatever our government has decided.

When I tell you "I ran a mile", I'm not telling someone in Australia I ran a mile. I"m telling you that. If we are speaking over the internet it might complicate things, but we only have to resolve the meaning of mile once for our relationship, and all proceeding discussions will use this meaning.

I would argue that this makes the word mile unambiguous in the sense that you are saying. If we had to assert each time what I meant by a mile, then that would be ambiguous.

> that sentence might not make any sense to someone reading it in 20 years

Evolution of language is a separate phenomenon. We don't need to consider that. Only what the language means today right now as I use it. That's the utility of language. For older English texts, we have literature which matches our common vernacular to the vernacular of the time. Foreign translations are out of scope for the same reason listed above. Since we have mappings between today's English and yesterday's English, I would again argue that this is not a source of ambiguity.

> And then when is today? May 7, 2019

That doesn't have anything to do with language. That is a chronospacial coordinate. It represents a certain degree of completion of our orbit around the sun. It isn't a measurement of time at all. It's only relative in the sense that all time and space measurements are relative to the spacetime coordinate of the Big Bang.

Time is inherently a relative concept. We don't have time unless we are comparing (relating) two different frames. We define one in terms relative to the other (motion, state, etc). In a single, non-relative frame of reference time just doesn't exist.

> And then finally, what if you were lying?

Again, this has nothing to do with language. You aren't trying to guess what I'm thinking, you're trying to understand what I'm saying. That's what language parsing is about. Discussion of motivations, misdirection, etc. is irrelevant.

Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by ta1234567890 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @12:00PM (#19869413)
Interesting. All of the above rebuttals are basically: ignore this because it's context and should be obvious.

Well, that's the problem. It might seem obvious to you now, but it is not obvious to everyone all the time, which is what makes any statement ambiguous.

Additionally, I don't know the purpose of what you are saying. For example, you might say you ran a mile because you wanted to express you were tired, or because you wanted to imply you are healthy, or who knows why, it is definitely not clear from the statement alone what you wanted to convey, which is the main problem.

We feel something internally and then we try to express that in words, hoping that those words will mean the same to the person perceiving them. That process is highly suceptible to noise in many forms, like the other person not hearing you correctly, being distracted, being stressed out, or maybe they speak a slightly different version of your language and some of the words or expressions mean something a bit different to them than to you.

In the end, any statement doesn't have meaning by itself, it only acquires meaning when someone interprets it and understands it in a certain way. That is always a subjective process.

Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by soulofmischief on Thursday May 09, 2019 @06:27PM (#19873054)
Honestly I feel like we could have a very deep conversation about this because I certainly agree with a lot of what you're saying.

Language is certainly subjective, but I would argue that we can make certain concessions on what context truly is "obvious" and what isn't. And I think the matter of what level of precision is acceptable enough to consider a statement or idea "understood" is up for debate and is also contextual.

At some point, any extra information is just that, extra information. The core idea may have been expressed fully, even if there are certain small ambiguities or if the listener wishes to draw insight from the statement beyond the basic sentiment expressed.

Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by ta1234567890 on Thursday May 09, 2019 @11:14PM (#19874749)
Completely agree with you.

Language is an incredibly useful tool and it works very well for most of our daily lives and many important things without thinking too much about it.

It's just very interesting to me to see how something that seems so solid, in some ways is much more fluid and fuzzy.

Thank you for keeping this thread going, really enjoyed discussing this.

Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by Rhinobird on Thursday May 09, 2019 @01:08PM (#19870066)
What if you walked an indeterminate length for an Airline mile?
Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by chacham15 on Friday May 10, 2019 @06:30PM (#19882872)
Even statements like this can become ambiguous depending on the speaker. E.g. is the speaker speaking literally or metaphorically? Maybe the speaker feels like they walked a lot and so they chose a distance which represented a lot to them. Also, is one mile a lot or a little? Maybe its the opposite and they feel like they barely walked. Science makes every attempt to be unambiguous, people do not.
Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by fwip on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @01:15PM (#19860947)
If anyone is interested in more sentences like these, check out garden path sentences.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Garden-path_sentence

Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by dtech on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @01:28PM (#19861055)
> The theory is that when everything in the sentence proceeds as predicted there's very little need to update prior expectations

Throwing exceptions is expensive

Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by nvrspyx on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @09:58PM (#19864706)
In psychology/neuroscience, many refer to this generally as heuristics. It’s astonishing how much the mind relies on these heuristics from aspects like language (as you’ve pointed out) to visual perception. Many think the main purpose is to speed up processing tasks and require less “resources” so that cognitive load is freed up for other things. One of my favorite examples of this is how car drivers seem to fall into a sort of “auto-pilot” mode freeing up resources to think about random things like what you’re going to eat for dinner once you get home.

I think the ELI5 way to look at it is pattern recognition and then using those patterns for not only prediction, much like ML models, but also in other things like physical actions, emotional response, etc.

Many theorize it is that these heuristics are trained and the “path more taken” is the default. It’s when a stimulus doesn’t fit that path that the brain has to decide whether:

1. Is something wrong with this?

2. Is this a new path I need to start paving to speed up future processing?

Whether or not that second choice is made is dependent on lots of things co-processing at the time: Emotion, attention, attitude, etc. How much that path is paved is also dependent on those things.

This idea is fundamental to areas of study like symbolic systems at Stanford [1]

[1]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Symbolic_Systems

Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by blattimwind on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @06:51PM (#19863708)
> You'll see a flash of activity when people read the word "sticky"

I noticed that my gaze actually jumped back to "jam" when I read "sticky".

Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by stubish on Thursday May 09, 2019 @12:51AM (#19865494)
And that flash of activity is also the basis of humor. We find unexpected things like this funny, the reward that helps our brains to analyze and learn from the unexpected situation.
Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by frereubu on Friday May 10, 2019 @04:02AM (#19875983)
Not all humour, but Steven Wright certainly made an entire career out of sentences like this.
Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by aportnoy on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @06:23PM (#19863544)
Re:Brains Speed Up Perception by Guessing What’s Next by wazer5 on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @10:27PM (#19864845)
I'm not surprised neuroscientists can measure it, I about fell over upon reading that sentence.