News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Liquid Death sells water by sonnyblarney on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @10:49AM (#19859309)
"It's always blowing my mind that smart/rich people invest time/energy/money in such useless ventures"

Consider that they are trying to make money, and from that premise, they are not 'useless ventures'.

All food products are commodities: even cola, energy drinks.

Coca Cola, RedBull are by far and away brands more than they are 'good products'.

Evian water sells for 30% more than unbranded water, that's the power of brand.

From a certain perspective, of course it's useless, because it's just branded water obviously, it's in a way offensive to our sensibilities ... but it's smart.

The brand is pretty good. It's a little risky but it almost makes sense.

In restaurants, they charge you more for branded water, and they make you feel like a dolt for drinking 'tap water'. They make a lot of money selling it.

This is the 'bar' equivalent: you can drink 'tap water' like a broke school kid or have a can of 'liquid death' while your bros drink up. Then you don't look like 'sissy' (or choose your own term if that offends the sensibilities). Obviously it's ridiculous, but that's what consumerism is.

I saw this in the news yesterday and immediately flagged it to my marketing friends. It's not a stupid idea.

Re:Liquid Death sells water by lenticular on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @11:02AM (#19859473)
It's not that you can't make money off it, it's that this sort of mindless unnecessary consumption has severe social and environmental consequences.
Re:Liquid Death sells water by NeedMoreTea on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @11:03AM (#19859480)
In terms of making money from empty marketing, come what may, it probably isn't a stupid idea.

In a world that's creaking under extreme pressure from climate, species and forest loss, and so on, it's an utterly reckless and stupid idea. That we have to learn to walk away from.

Quite happy to be the uncool kid (a stretch at my age, but hey) drinking tap water, ta. :)

Re:Liquid Death sells water by tarr11 on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @11:08AM (#19859522)
Curious if you’d give up your tea for ecological reasons?

(Making some assumptions from your username ;)

https://oxfordre.com/environmentalscience/view/10.1093/acref...

Re:Liquid Death sells water by NeedMoreTea on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @11:16AM (#19859586)
On the basis of a very fast skim and the conclusion, their grounds appear to apply to 99% of agriculture. I'd have to give up eating.

"However, the tea industry has a high impact on the environment. While being monoculture, it is hub a particular type of fauna, it is ecologically friendly, that is, not harmful to the environment, absorbs greenhouse gases, and supports tea-tourism. However, it also raises certain concerns, including the huge use of pesticides and irrational use of chemical fertilizers."

No idea how it compares to coffee, coke, canned water or anything really, but the conclusion implies it may be one of the least-worst options.

If it turns out tea was worse than other beverage options, yes I would. We've already made significant changes, and expect to make more - from choice and mandated before my time here is done. :)

Re:Liquid Death sells water by lenticular on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @03:52PM (#19862254)
Giving up tea presumably would mean giving up something the poster presumably finds pleasurable. Drinking tap water instead of bottled has no such trade off. There's a big difference between asking people to live like monks and asking them to not consume things that give them little to no value.
Re:Liquid Death sells water by bluGill on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @11:19AM (#19859626)
While branded water does sell for more, if you look closely you discover that bottled water buyers are not nearly as brand loyal as other drink buyers are (most cola drinkers have tried both Coke and Pepsi and can tell the difference, most water buyers have likewise tried off brands and been unable to tell the difference). Store brand water sells very well in general.
Re:Liquid Death sells water by Retra on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @11:03AM (#19859482)
So you're saying if I can make money doing something, then it is both ethical and smart?
Re:Liquid Death sells water by sonnyblarney on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @11:14AM (#19859574)
I didn't say that.

We all agree it's kind of dumb, pragmatically.

Mostly what I'm trying to do is convey to some commenters here what seems to be a common lack of understanding in tech (maybe a good thing) as to how and why people buy goods and services.

When one understand this, one understands why it's a 'good' business plan.

Also - we - all of us - are woefully unaware of how poignant and powerful all of this is. It works on all of us and 100% of the consumer goods we buy - and even many 'tech goods' are brand and aspirationaly oriented.

Tech is full of ridiculous fads and memes; when I go to tech conferences we play a game of 'count the allbirds' (shoes) as kind of a joke.

But even for actual tech products: Google, FB, Snapchat, Apple (obviously), MS, to some extent Twitter - those are heavy brands, even if they weren't derived from a bunch of marketing people ... 'Do No Evil' ended up being an important lynchpin of Google branding efforts. Way way back in about the year 2000, Google was running ads on NPR and their ethos and manner was presented ultimately as quite different than other tech companies. It was part of their messaging, however authentic.

So - no, I would not want to do this business, I would not want to support it, and I hope I never buy this ridiculous water. But I know my snowboarding brother and his friends will ...

Re:Liquid Death sells water by Retra on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @11:21AM (#19859660)
If you start with the assumption that 100% of purchases are aspirational, it is no surprise that you reach this conclusion. But I will seriously question that assumption, simply because there are many other reasons to purchase a product. The vast majority of purchases I make are decided by distribution, not marketing. You seem to be measuring things in such a way as to never see the difference.
[dead]
Re:Liquid Death sells water by Retra on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @11:15AM (#19859578)
What a useless sentiment that is.
Re:Liquid Death sells water by matz1 on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @11:17AM (#19859596)
Maybe, but that is the reality.
Re:Liquid Death sells water by Retra on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @11:59AM (#19860121)
The reality is that truths without relevance are no better than fantasies.
Re:Liquid Death sells water by matz1 on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @12:23PM (#19860359)
How is that not relevant? If making money is part of my ethics, which is for many people (including me) are, then the answer to your original question, is yes it is ethical.
Re:Liquid Death sells water by Retra on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @02:11PM (#19861436)
I'm not asking if morality is subjective, I'm asking how to reconcile a difference between two moralities. Pointing out that people think differently on such matters is not only obvious, it is something I had to assume before even asking the question.

What were you hoping to achieve with your comment?

Re:Liquid Death sells water by matz1 on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @02:39PM (#19861678)
Ok now you are asking different question.

>how to reconcile a difference between two moralities

What is there to reconcile? I simply do whatever I personally think its ethical.

>What were you hoping to achieve with your comment

Simply answering your question

Re:Liquid Death sells water by Retra on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @03:42PM (#19862173)
Your entire comment history is filled with the same "I don't have to answer to anybody" style of argument. You were not simply trying to answer my question. You didn't even bother to try to understand it. You're on some kind of craven ideological power trip.
Re:Liquid Death sells water by matz1 on Wednesday May 08, 2019 @03:58PM (#19862302)
I am answering your question as the best I can. If there is misunderstanding or something I misunderstood, you can simply point that out.