Re:Ask HN: Cognitive Science vs Computer Science
by _delirium on Thursday December 09, 2010 @01:27AM
(#1986380)
> Does anyone take academic HCI seriously in industry?
Microsoft, Yahoo, IBM, and Google have fairly big academic-leaning HCI groups as far as I can tell; they even publish quite a bit at places like CHI. Apart from machine learning, graphics, and storage systems, it's one of the easier areas for a Ph.D. to get hired in industry.
I would not say that CompSci "stifles creativity", nor even that it ignores web development entirely (although that's a murkier point, and mobile is too new for most universities to teach it, which is just how it goes). But I would say that the overlap between what universities know how to teach, and what is relevant to working software development (in emerging areas and in well-travelled areas) is very small indeed, perhaps a few percent of each.
When advising my lead on a hire/no-hire decision, I would give absolutely no weight to the degree or lack thereof, and would give weight to a combination of 1) real experience, and 2) my (flawed and subjective) judgement of intelligence and skills.
All that said, apparently some companies still value the piece of paper. I think there are three levels of degree-ness from those companies' perspective: correct degree (cmpt, eng, maybe math), other degree(english lit, archeology), no degree. And I think that those companies will see a CogSci degree as virtually equivalent to a History degree: "Oh, I guess he's got a degree, so that's nice, but the content of the degree is not what we might hire him for".
Does anyone take academic HCI seriously in industry?