The internet has no filter. Information flows at a steady constant pace; in fact most communication now a days can take place immediately. This has its pros and cons. Pros, well its awesome. Cons, without a filter many people will jump on a bandwagon without knowing the full details of a situation.
Sometimes people do not think as logically as they think they are. Acting on hearsay and emotions alone will lead people to act reckless, and once that stone starts rolling it's hard to stop; zerg.
This should not be taken as a generalization of online networks as there are outliers in most situations. This is just a reminder that not everyone on the internet has other people best interest in mind. Some people are just mean.
The best relationships are somewhere in the middle.
What about a government doing as it sees fit? That should be more frightening to you because it's existing for a long time and it's cost countless lives. And it's still doing so.
Of course, a government has the ability to influence a situation more than the Internet; they can pretty much do what ever they want. I don't see them throwing that weight around to much though. In fact, if the Wikileaks documents has taught anyone anything, it is that the government is on its grind 24-7 365.
Dont get me wrong. DDoSing Paypal, Master Card, et al is pretty entertaining, but I wonder what that cost other people? They screwed with an individual organization, well they have millions of clients. Instead of giving the situation time to develop, the Internet took the easy path to instant gratification, destruction.
If you mess with ourIdol(X) we(Y) will not hesitate to take you(Z) down, and not care about them(ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVW)
A better solution would have been: Get the news. Allow the news to sink in. What is the gravity of the situation? Are there any opposing arguments? Let those arguments sink in. Rationally, which view is better? Has the news changed yet? Form opinion. Talk to opposition. Plan. Attack.
All of that should take at least a 1 or 2 days. Internet, their on it in like 5 minutes.
I suspect you don't know much about anarchy if you think it's without order. It's just (according to the literature) without inequality.
>but I wonder what that cost other people?
At this point, there is pretty much no action you could take that would have any effect on the people you wish to motivate without affecting innocent people as well. Deciding to not use a monopoly business only has negative affect on you, not the monopoly. They wont even notice.
I don't see any reason to believe it went down that way.
It's probable it was a group who already had much of the ability in-place to execute an attack like this, and who decided to target mastercard.com because it was found to be vulnerable, or because paypal and amazon were out of thier reach.
Economist / Babbage: http://www.economist.com/blogs/babbage/2010/12/more_wikileak... (I think he gets the definition of OP wrong, but everything else seems to jive with my non-firsthand understanding.)
First, let's stipulate that 4chan's Anonymous raids are mostly juvenile and often ineffective at doing anything meaningful to their targets.
At the same time: The ability of a community to completely self-organize, without central direction, and instantly execute a publicly-visible plan like this is without precedent in human history.
It stands to reason that as time goes on, larger groups of people will become involved in communities that exhibit 4chan-like cohesion. A larger pool means a higher likelihood of these groups including people with the knowledge and ability to do ever-increasing damage.
The long-term implications are interesting. Into the future, are we talking about the instant formation and dissolution of "terrorist" or "dissident" groups, bound together by transient common interest and gone again within days or hours? If you're a government or corporation, this is terrifying. You can keep tabs on other governments, and even traditional terrorist cells, which each move at the speed of the usual group dynamics, proportional to their size.
But what the hell do you do about groups you can't predict that are gone before you even figure out what's wrong? Groups that aren't bound together by national identity or other easily quantified affiliations – just ideas, ideals and transient events?
There's something meaningful here that points to how we all get along in the future, in the same vein as the "post-secrecy world" presaged by Wikileaks-style activism enabled by network technologies.
Or maybe I just need a nap.