Tampering with paper elections is extremely easy. You can throw out entire ballots, fill in choices where left blank, or force the ballot into an invalid state.
Not to mention the task of counting ballots using people necessarily requires splitting up the task and trusting people.
Electronic voting systems are supposed to address many of these problems, especially as processing the election becomes laborious. We don't need to give up on electronic counting solutions. We just need to make them impervious to tampering and/or verifiable.
>But it is far better than trusting a computer, that by definition "can do everything computable". And falsifying an election is definitly computable.
Tallying up votes by hand is also computation, you're just switching silicon for people.
Hard to do this while you're being watched by observers though...
And if you need to recruit many people to make your tampering scheme work, then it's much harder to keep it a secret.
Well that said, I don't think its the "best" solution per se. It is wasteful -- a lot of paper must be produced for this single task. It is not completely free of loopholes, but they are burdensome and can be verified by a second count. And I can understand why countries like e.g. India or Indonesia use computers in this situation, millions upon millions of people cast their vote over a limited time period -- it's a logistical nightmare.
But it is far better than trusting a computer, that by definition "can do everything computable". And falsifying an election is definitly computable.