News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany proposes $2,800 fine for parents skipping measles... by ponow on Monday May 06, 2019 @12:55PM (#19841276)
"Reckless"? You mean sub-optimal. Sure, if the issue is spreading disease people outside one's family, then fine away. But choices whose primary consequences are to be borne by the family, ought to stay within the family. Actually, a reasonable starting fine is the expected cost of healthcare outside the family due to non-immunization by the family.
Re:Germany proposes $2,800 fine for parents skipping measles... by maze-le on Monday May 06, 2019 @01:23PM (#19841633)
No I do mean "reckless". It is one thing to have no knowledge about a topic and act accordingly, it's quite another to be in active denial about a topic that has been proven again and again.

>> Actually, a reasonable starting fine is the expected cost of healthcare outside the family due to non-immunization by the family.

Well, its damn hard for anyone immunocompromised (under immunosuppressive therapy or by disease). They have a higher chance of dying, a death that could be prevented if herd immunity would be reached. They are not just a costly externality.

Re:Germany proposes $2,800 fine for parents skipping measles... by convolvatron on Monday May 06, 2019 @02:19PM (#19842214)
it would be so much easier if we could just assign a dollar amount to each human life. then the insurance industry could perform its normal risk-management function.

since clearly all lives dont have the same economic value, and the market is really the only effective process to ascribe such a value - slavery is really most natural framework to sort all this out.

as a plus, we also dont have to have all those stupid discussions about trollies and track switches anymore.

Re:Germany proposes $2,800 fine for parents skipping measles... by fzeroracer on Monday May 06, 2019 @03:57PM (#19843151)
Okay, let's take your argument to the extreme.

You say that choices whose primary consequences are to be born by the family ought to stay with the family.

With that logic established, do you believe violence against family members is permitted? How about psychological harm or abuse?

Your logic doesn't hold up because we've established that certain things are Bad regardless if it's self-contained within a family unit. Ergo, vaccinations should be included as something that should be included. Avoiding vaccinations I argue is tantamount to child abuse.