As somebody paying for Spotify, I agree. As somebody who had a MP3 collection on his disk in the 2000s, I disagree. Without doubt, my wifi connection should make it easy and fast to synchronize music between my laptop and smartphone. Nevertheless, "moving to the cloud" favours a centralized setup. Thankfully we see more decentralization on the horizon.
With music (and videos, and games) there's also another angle that I believe is in big part responsible for the success of Spotify and similar services: they provide an alternative between the only two options people had before - either spend a lot of money buying music in unwieldy formats, or acquire MP3s from copyright infringers.
Re:UX clichés
by pavel_lishin on Tuesday May 07, 2019 @10:15AM
(#19849553)
I totally agree with you, there should be a self-hosted option. I'd love it if the Google Play API was sufficiently reverse-engineered to just install a modified version of their software to point to my own server.
I've asked for open-source/self-hosted solutions before, and a few people here responded. One of the solutions looks like it promises to do what I want, though I haven't had a solid chance to look at it: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19555899
Maybe in terms of the things you can click and knobs you can twiddle, but moving my music into Google Play and off (e.g.) iTunes means that I can very trivially put music on my mobile device (using either that device, or the computer) that is almost instantly accessible offline, and easy to listen to.
That twin gain - ease of sync and offline availability - completely blew Winamp and iTunes so far out of the water that they're in orbit, as far as I'm concerned.
(There are things I miss; multiple genres for a given song/album. Organizing by folder and playlist. Visualizations. Sometimes Google Play will forcibly replace my uploaded files with the wrong version - I still have a few songs that are "censored", and it grates me whenever I hear them.)