But while there are certainly many small businesses for which this is not true, for the billionaires and Fortune 500 companies, increasing wages would not decrease profit enough to actually change their lifestyle. At least for many, all it would change would be the number they see when they look at one of their many bank accounts.
In the meantime, the low wages mean that the "lifestyle" of a great many in the US is that of working poverty, not knowing whether they will be able to make rent and food in a given month, and certainly not being able to afford much in the way of leisure.
This presumes a closed system, and the assumption is demonstrably false in at least two ways. With an open system, you can conceivably have growth for both sides of the market (profit and wages).
For one, we are extracting energy and resources from nature, and the supply - at least of energy - is effectively unlimited. Longer term we can also mine the resources from outer space, which again is effectively unlimited. Granted, there are constraints on how quickly we can build out the gathering infrastructure for either, but there is no hard cap. Moreover, with the improvements in efficiency (economies and environmentalism go hand in hand here) we're reducing waste and reusing a lot resources and energy that would've previously been wasted, again moving the needle away from resource limitation and towards open-like system.
For another, the discussion is implicitly about USA (and similar case can be made for EU), meanwhile there's well known trade imbalance with goods purchased from abroad. Getting close to, or at, the point of balance is feasible; the current imbalance is result of difference in economical conditions and governmental policy.
The goods imported from abroad are specifically the ones that are mass-manufactured, which is where the wage laborers gets their wages from. The suppressed demand for local manufacturing suppresses wages of workers within USA (similarly, within EU).
Effectively we have outsourced the growth of wages to other countries. Making the source countries richer obviously has important benefits (stabilizing them politically, long term making them interested in clean environment, etc.), but it is a policy choice that needs to be balanced with in-country prosperity none the less.
And then there's the matter of changes in supply of workers, but that's a whole different subject for another day.
All in all, sure, reform capitalism: improve the trade balance, let the wages recover due to the demand that's already present, just supplied for from elsewhere.
Unless you're proposing we print money, it is a closed system. There is a relatively finite amount of money, growth, and consumption in any economy.
We've seen over the last 40 years that without concerted effort on the side of the working class, the owning class will keep and push wages low while keeping the gains of growth to themselves. It's well known that efficiency has increased while wages have barely grown.
No one is going to willingly share their profit with you, especially the lower you are in your income / skill level. That's why the average McDonalds employee in the US creates about $70,000/yr in profit and receives on average $18,000/yr.
Yes of course; with a quarterly growth GDP currently around 3%[1], we should and indeed do "print" money at related rate. (again, with the assumption we're discussing USA here).
However my argument hinges on two other aspects: the system is open in regard to energy gathering and resource gathering. The system (again, assuming we're discussing USA) is also open in regard to outside trade - USA can't completely control the policy and state of economy of trade partners. Are you proposing we close up the borders and/or cap energy & resource extraction & waste recovery?
>without concerted effort on the side of the working class, the owning class will keep and push wages low while keeping the gains of growth to themselves
A salient observation.
>It's well known that efficiency has increased while wages have barely grown.
It is also well known the pool of labor supply has grown significantly.
I propose we slow down the supply of labor a bit, to help the price of labor go up naturally, without any forceful methods. Care to join me on this quest? It works well for every segment of work market where it's implemented: doctors, lawyers, licensed engineers, you name it.
[1] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/us-gdp-grew-3-2-in-the-first-qu...
Wealth inequality seems like a proxy metric for "the lower classes are struggling". Is the correlation (or causation?) between the two well established?
Does this boil down to the fact that, in the current political system, wealth can be traded for political power, and if that exchange didn't exist, then wealth wouldn't be an issue in the first place?
No. Money can buy manpower, resources, time, and political access. Power can buy the laws in your favor and access to resources and manpower and make time in your favor.
> Let's say I'm ok with Steve Jobs hoarding billions
The surplus should have went to the workers. The fact he uses the surplus as his primarily personal slush fund to then reuse is an abomination.
> he creates something game-changing for society over decades of starting/running a business
Anybody could create something game-changing for society. Just because someone isn't acting for shitty SV style actions (make money on exploiting others), doesn't mean it could be game-changing. And people could start doing once their wages were not stagnating and held down.
> as long as that doesn't mean his vote is more important than that of an entire state.
It was worth that much, and other CEOs it too is worth the same.
I've seen time and again the refrain of "We'll bring good jobs in this area, give us a 10 year tax abatement, and do all these improvements". Long story short, the jobs suck, the company moves in free of taxes, sucks off the teat of the city, and then leaves for somewhere else to start the scam all over.
The deal (power) sounds too good with all the money surrounding the plan. And, it is. But Mr. Mayor gets to take claim of a pile of jobs, new industry, and something about revitalization. By the time the smoke clears, Mr Mayor will be long gone up the political foodchain.
Money and power go hand in hand. Power can be converted through time into money. And Money can be converted into power over time.
I think so. Finding ways to completely eliminate that exchange is a challenge, however. Most of the exchange exists in wealth being able to buy a louder voice, either through lobbying or in the media. It would hard to break that without introducing some other inequity.
Why does money buy power? As state control expands and authoritarian thinking is embraced by both parties in the United States, there is more centralized power TO purchase.
It is in everyone's best interest at the top (politicians and billionaires alike) that government continues to expand the size and scope of their aims, while keeping taxes low. Not so much for the average and poor people, but this seems obvious.
It’s just empirically untrue propaganda.
Both turn to authoritarianism to solve their problems. One party just happens to be more moral in doing so. That makes them preferable, somewhat. But friendly to libertarianism, neither party is, and calling it for what it is doesn't make me an ally of anyone.
The same way people don't join unions if they think they will make less money because of their union dues. They do these things as a means to improving their material conditions.
The problem is that one "tribe"'s material conditions are at the expense of the others. You can't increase wages without decreasing profit. So the profiting "tribe" is at odds with the wage "tribe".
I'm scare-quoting "tribe" because the traditional word is class which we've had ironed out of us over the last 40 years. This is class struggle and has existed for a long time.